Best Pellet Grills According to r/pelletgrills (December 2025)

tldr; Most-discussed pellet grill with divided opinions. Praised for build quality and rotisserie, but premium price draws comparisons to better-value alternatives.

tldr; Reddit's favorite mid-range pellet grill with 73% positive sentiment - the highest in its class. Users praise the build quality, customer service, and value.

tldr; Reddit highly recommends the Yoder YS640s for its phenomenal, tank-like build quality, consistent temperatures, and versatile capabilities for smoking, grilling, and searing.

tldr; One of Reddit's most recommended mid-range pellet grills with 70% positive sentiment. Users praise the build quality, PID controller accuracy, and excellent customer service.

tldr; Highly recommended by Reddit for its versatility and smoke box feature. Users praise the ability to add propane sidekick attachments.

tldr; 702 sq in flagship with 16-gauge stainless steel. PID controller holds temps within 5F, legendary customer service.

tldr; Reddit generally recommends the Grilla Grills Chimp for its WiFi features and ample cooking space, though some users reported initial wiring issues.

tldr; Reddit generally praises the Camp Chef XXL Pro as an efficient, dedicated vertical smoker with a 'game changer' smoke box that enhances flavor, and it's.

tldr; Limited specific discussion on Reddit. The Traveler is Country Smokers' portable pellet grill option.

tldr; 570 sq in mid-size with smoke box technology. Sidekick attachment expands to full outdoor kitchen setup.

tldr; Reddit highly regards Lone Star Grillz pellet smokers as a top-tier, high-quality option, often considered superior to competitors like Yoder, with excellent build and versatile.

tldr; Reddit generally finds the Pit Boss Austin XL to be a reliable, versatile, and good-value pellet grill that consistently performs well.

tldr; Larger version of the highly-rated Silverbac. Reddit praises the extra cooking space while maintaining Grilla's build quality and customer service.

tldr; Sam's Club exclusive that Reddit considers an excellent value. Essentially a rebranded Louisiana Grills at a lower price.

tldr; 573 sq in workhorse under $500 on sale. Ash cleanout system and PID controller match pricier competitors.

tldr; Reddit highly praises the Traeger Ironwood XL for its exceptional reliability, super consistent temperature control, and ease of use, leading to consistently good barbecue results.

tldr; Reddit's favorite portable/small pellet grill. The Bullseye excels at high-heat grilling and pizza with its 749°F capability.

tldr; Reddit has mixed feelings about the Ironwood. WiFIRE connectivity and D2 controller are praised, but many feel it's overpriced.

tldr; 1,236 sq in of cooking space with game-changing smoke box for wood chunks. Sidekick compatible for added versatility.

tldr; Budget-friendly pellet grill that Reddit considers excellent value. The 700 series offers solid performance at a lower price point.

tldr; 575 sq in entry-level with WiFire connectivity. Easy to use but thin construction and better value alternatives exist.

tldr; Cabinet-style vertical with large smoking capacity. Excellent for sausage hanging but no grilling capability.

tldr; Reddit has mixed feelings about the Grilla Grills Silverbac Alpha Connect; while older models are loved for quality, newer ones are criticized for declining build.

tldr; 849 sq in with flame broiler for direct grilling. PID controller improved Gen 2 but thin metal rusts without cover.