tldr; Reddit overwhelmingly recommends the Alienware AW3425DW. With 88% positive sentiment across 74 mentions, this is a clear community favorite.
$749.99 on AmazonScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for Alienware AW3425DW
“Alienware AW3425DW Purchased from the high praise the 2023 panel received on Reddit and respectable sources like Rtings, Monitors Unboxed.”
“I bought 3425dw and had to return it because of eye strain. It was the worst return I ever did and it was not even a RMA. Supposedly their courier was supposed to come collect the monitor at my home, but the first problem was that they didn't give me a return label, I had to go back and forth multiple emails to finally have one, then their courier never came, said I wasn't home when I clearly was. I had to escalate the issue and make multiple calls until they finally sent someone, after that they received the monitor 3-4 days after the pickup but the tracking was still stuck on "prepare for pickup someone will get your return" when the package clearly arrived. I had to email them again and wait another 15 days to finally get my refund. Almost 2 months of back and forth with an useless support at almost every step of the return to make a return. I almost missed my return window thanks to their bullshit of delaying the pickup, the courrier picked up the package once the 30 days had passed (even tho I asked for the return way before that). And mind you this was only a return, I can't even imagine what would their support be like for a defective product”
74 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 4/4/2026