tldr; Reddit has mixed results with The Inkey List Caffeine Eye Cream; while affordable, many find it doesn't significantly improve dark circles which are often genetic.
Check pricesScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for The Inkey List Caffeine Eye Cream
“my skin type is combination, dehydrated, sensitive, and acne prone products in order routine: byoma milky jelly cleanser - i’m so picky about cleansers, and i honestly don’t love how it kind of strips my skin, but the texture is tolerable and it doesn’t take forever to wash off like some other cleansers. tonymoly ceramide mochi toner - HUGE toner that’s super hydrating and affordable, i believe it has essential oils but it doesn’t irritate my skin bubble moon walk exfoliating serum - this is supposed to be super gentle but i’ve seen some irritation with it, it’s not as irritating when my face is dry though. it’s new so i haven’t seen results yet numbuzin no. 3 serum - a serum that reduces skin texture, i haven’t seen results with this yet but i got it pretty recently so i’ll keep using it purito centella unscented serum - ugh i love this it’s so hydrating and gives my skin a bit of glow too, it’s a barrier serum so it helps repair the skin barrier too differin adapalene gel - ive been using this retinoid for a longggg time now, i don’t even remember what my skin is like without it the inkey list caffeine eye cream - reduces dark circles pretty well i thinkkk first aid beauty ultra repair cream - i have mixed feelings about this moisturizer. it has a nice thick texture but my skin still feels tight when i use it, i ordered a new moisturizer that’s more lightweight because i find that lightweight creams make my dehydrated areas feel less tight.”
1,425 mentions
1,405 mentions
740 mentions
658 mentions
501 mentions
414 mentions
14 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 2/24/2026