tldr; Women's Exos. Same quality, different fit. Women's pick.
$284.95 on AmazonScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for Osprey Eja 58
“I went from a 2 lb 3 oz Hyperlite Southwest 55 that was killing my shoulders to a 2 lb 11 oz Osprey Eja 58 and the heavier pack is way more comfortable for me because it actually transfers the weight to my hips. I just went on a trip where things went sideways and I had to carry someone else’s gear and probably had about 45 lbs in that thing and it was okay and my shoulders were fine.”
“I have the Eja (currently trying to sell it actually) and it hurt me SO BAD. I have a short torso (16 in) so I bought the XS (fits 13-17h) and the molded frame that is supposed to sit on the hip dig into me so bad that I had actual horrible bruises after our hike. Mind you it was only a one night. However…that being said…it could just be the way it fit MY body. I’ve read great reviews about the EJA which is why I bought it. Unfortunately it just didn’t fit me well. I’d just be aware of the frame that comes down and sits on the tops of the butt cheek area. It was awful for me.”
27 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 4/4/2026