Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot vs R.M. Williams Comfort Craftsman

“Recently got these OSB trench boots in black CXL on sale, thought I'd post some initial thoughts here for discussion. Sizing: 8E/EE brannock with wide instep and narrow heel, followed their sizing guide and got size 8 in their Elston last. Fit: The fit is quite nice, nothing much to complain here. They are very snug/slightly tight out of the box all-round without any pressure points. It has been a little over a week of daily wear and the CXL is breaking in very nicely. Virtually no heel slip, would like a little more room in the toe box but this is not bad at all. Style/build: I strongly disagree with those who say these look like duck feet. That said, they are definitely not the most sleek silhouette out there. My frame of reference is quite limited as I am relatively new to heritage/GYW boots, but I'd rate its shape above the old Thursday RT3 last which I own and was famous for being too round at the front. Like what Thursday did with the new Kingmaker last, (as well as the parkhurst 602M) I think the Elston would benefit stylistically from a slightly elongated toe box to match the added width and maintain a more almond-shaped toe. That said, this his is only my opinion, and I am still happy with how these look as-is. I did put some new flat cotton laces on instead of the factory raw hide laces, but that's just a personal preference. In terms of build, I would really appreciate at least one more set of speed hooks (these have two) to help taking them on and off. These also have ungussetted tongues. I would prefer a semi-gussetted tongue, but it's not a make-or-break for me. Finish/QC: I feel like I have seen a disproportionally high number of posts and comments regarding OSB's shoddy finish and QC. I am happy to report that I cannot spot any defect/QC issues that are worth mentioning. My only nitpick is that the break/creasings on the vamps are not the best (as you can probably tell from the pictures), and that the quarters somehow have better, more "buttery" creases. I am happy to sweep this under the carpet of "CXL lottery", but maybe this can be improved by better clicking. Final thoughts: In terms of finishing and feel, I would say these feel less premium and well-made than the pair of Parkhurst I own, which is in the same price bracket as OSB but quite a bit cheaper at MSRP. Note that OSB is made in USA and Parkhurst is made in Spain, so that may be a point of consideration for some. I have read that both Grant Stone and Parkhusrt are better made than OSB in the same-ish price range, but again, only OSB is made in USA. All in all, I think these are OK for the price I paid, though I am not too sure if I would pay the full MSRP knowing the QC risks. If QC is not an issue and they add a semi-gusseted tongue, I would 100% buy them again and recommend them to others.”

“RM Williams comfort craftsman are significantly more comfortable in my opinion. Objectively they are much more formal and subjectively I think they are a lot better looking compared to blundstones as well. However they are quite pricey, but worth it imo.”