Blundstone 500 vs Thursday Captain

105 facts in comparison

Based on 282 Reddit opinions. Blundstone 500 leads by 14 points.

282 opinions
Blundstone 500 leads by 14pts
Reddit's Pick
Blundstone 500
76%
B
Based on
241 Redditors
Winner

Blundstone 500

~$199.95
112 opinions

tldr; The everyday Chelsea. Slip-on convenience, decent durability. Not GYW but practical.

Check prices
VS
Thursday Captain
62%
C
Based on
445 Redditors

Thursday Captain

170 opinions

tldr; Thursday's flagship boot. Best entry-level GYW option. Good styling, budget quality. Gateway boot.

Check prices
Leather QualityConstructionComfort & Break-inDurabilityFit & Sizing
⭐LEA
⭐CON
ā¤ļøCOM
šŸ”§DUR
šŸ“FIT
67
Points
54
Points

Score by Category

Leather Quality
0%50%
Construction
50%23%
Comfort & Break-in
84%54%
Durability
82%76%
Fit & Sizing
50%39%

Why is Thursday Captain better than Blundstone 500?

  • Better value (83% vs 71%)
  • Found secondhand for ~$40-80
  • Resolable, wedge sole conversion popular
  • Viberg 2030-inspired silhouette
Based on 686 Reddit opinions
Clear Winner

Reddit prefers the Blundstone 500

Winning by 14 points (76% vs 62%)

Better comfort
Better durability
Better construction
High confidence (686 mentions)

šŸ’¬Reddit Sentiment

Based on 686 Reddit mentions

Overall Rating

Blundstone 500
7.6/10
241 mentions
Thursday Captain
6.2/10
445 mentions
COMFORT
Blundstone 5008.4/10
Thursday Captain5.4/10
DURABILITY
Blundstone 5008.2/10
Thursday Captain7.6/10
CONSTRUCTION
Blundstone 5005.0/10
Thursday Captain2.3/10
VALUE
Blundstone 5007.1/10
Thursday Captain8.3/10
LEATHER QUALITY
Blundstone 5000.0/10
Thursday Captain5.0/10
FIT
Blundstone 5005.0/10
Thursday Captain3.9/10
āš”ļø

Head to Head

Head to Head

Blundstone 500: 4|Thursday Captain: 2
ComfortBlundstone 500
Blundstone 50084%
Thursday Captain54%
DurabilityBlundstone 500
Blundstone 50082%
Thursday Captain76%
ConstructionBlundstone 500
Blundstone 50050%
Thursday Captain23%
ValueThursday Captain
Blundstone 50071%
Thursday Captain83%
Leather QualityThursday Captain
Blundstone 5000%
Thursday Captain50%
FitBlundstone 500
Blundstone 50050%
Thursday Captain39%
Blundstone 50076%
Thursday Captain62%
Blundstone 500 wins by 14 points

Key Specs

SpecBlundstone 500Thursday Captain
Upper Material
Premium leather
Thursday Chrome Leather, WeatherSafe Suede
Outsole
TPU outsole
Studded rubber outsoles, DuraEVA Comfort Strip
Midsole
PU midsole
—
Lining
Unlined or partially lined
Full glove leather
Shock Absorption
SPS Max Comfort system
—

Key Highlights

Blundstone 500Winner
šŸ‡¦šŸ‡ŗ Australian brand
šŸ‘Ÿ Slip-on ease
ā˜” Weather resistant
šŸ’° Affordable
šŸ“¦ Not resoleable
Thursday Captain
šŸ’° Found secondhand for ~$40-80
šŸ› ļø Resolable, wedge sole conversion popular
šŸ‘ž Viberg 2030-inspired silhouette
šŸ‘… Tongue slippage common complaint
āš ļø Foam sock liner deteriorates

Topic Battles

Blundstone 500: 4|Tied: 0|Thursday Captain: 1
⭐Leather Quality
Thursday Captain wins
Blundstone 500
0%
Thursday Captain
50%
⭐Construction
Blundstone 500 wins
Blundstone 500
50%
Thursday Captain
23%
ā¤ļøComfort & Break-in
Blundstone 500 wins
Blundstone 500
84%
Thursday Captain
54%
šŸ”§Durability
Blundstone 500 wins
Blundstone 500
82%
Thursday Captain
76%
šŸ“Fit & Sizing
Blundstone 500 wins
Blundstone 500
50%
Thursday Captain
39%

Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories

šŸ“ˆWhere They Rank

šŸ’¬What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Blundstone 500

Best Praise
+43 pts
ā€œBlundstones with good insoles. You’d be hard pressed to find a better all-purpose shoe (yes, even for summer)ā€
r/malefashionadvice
View
Top Criticism
+5 pts
ā€œMy blundstones failed and they refused to replace them. My girlfriends failed in the exact same way and they replaced hers. I switched to redblacks, as they are better made and won't fail in the same way. Their service soured me.ā€
r/malefashionadvice
View
3 more quotes available below

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Thursday Captain

Best Praise
+61 pts
ā€œI am on the precipice of retiring my Thursdays after 7 years and thought it would be good to come here and share my thoughts. I wrote a review on here about 76.5 years ago talking about the purchase being okay but horrible sole issues (chunks missing). Thursday found my review, reached out, and offered to compensate me to get them repaired at a cobbler. I took them up on this and put Vibram soles on them... We now sit here 7 years later and the boots have held up very well. I spend a good 2 years being a responsible owner, keeping them moisturized and brushed. Those habits eventually died and I can say the boots have held up great. This boot made my fall in love with Horween CXL leathers, having now ordered basically all leather goods specifically in that leather now. I now sit here with shoes that finally need re-soled again after 6.5 hard-wearing years and have made the decision to order a new pair of boots instead of repairing these again. With that said, I am making plans to order Grant Stones this time around as they seem the best next-level option for a Brand that also carries Horween CXL boots (just torn between Natural and Crimson colors). Hope this review helps any beginners out there!ā€
r/goodyearwelt
View
Top Criticism
+21 pts
ā€œI've had such a suboptimal opinion on Thursdays, but it's only based off the one pair of Captains I had for a couple of years. Notably, the tongue sliding off center annoyed the hell outta me. So, I did watch the Rose Anvil video that featured his Thursday collab and it was validating for him to mention the tongue being gussetted. Kudos for sharing. As an everyday beater pair, sounds like it fills your use case pretty well. I just can't personally get over how 'off' and dull Thursday leather looks and feels. More contrast on the heel stack would really help too. Good to know, however, that the leather shank is serving you well, especially considering the pain you've endured from that motorcycle accident you mentioned, yikes! Thanks for sharing your experience with these!ā€
r/goodyearwelt
View
3 more quotes available below

šŸ“ˆHistorical Price Data

Blundstone 500
Thursday Captain
$180$190$200$210Mar '19Aug '25Aug '25Jan '26Mar '26May '26Low: $199.95
Blundstone 500
All-time low: $89(2017-05)
Thursday Captain

Which is Better?

Blundstone 500 Wins
76%
500
vs
62%
Captain

Blundstone 500 leads by 14 points based on 686 Reddit opinions.

Why Blundstone 500Winner
  • šŸ‡¦šŸ‡ŗ Australian brand
  • šŸ‘Ÿ Slip-on ease
  • ā˜” Weather resistant
Why Thursday Captain
  • Better Value for Money (83% vs 71%)
  • More discussed (445 vs 241)

ā¤ļøThe Love/Hate Breakdown

Sentiment Breakdown

36%Positive
Positive
36%
Neutral
53%
Negative
11%
Based on 241 Reddit opinions

Sentiment Breakdown

23%Positive
Positive
23%
Neutral
61%
Negative
16%
Based on 445 Reddit opinions

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Blundstone 500 or Thursday Captain?
Based on 686 Reddit comments, Blundstone 500 is the preferred choice with 76% positive sentiment vs Thursday Captain's 62%. Blundstone 500 leads by 14 percentage points.
Should I buy Blundstone 500 or Thursday Captain?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Blundstone 500 has stronger approval ratings (76% vs 62%). However, Thursday Captain may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about Blundstone 500?
Reddit users highlight: Australian brand. Slip-on ease. Weather resistant. With 241 mentions and 76% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Thursday Captain?
Reddit users highlight: Found secondhand for ~$40-80. Resolable, wedge sole conversion popular. Viberg 2030-inspired silhouette. With 445 mentions and 62% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 686 Reddit comments: 241 about Blundstone 500 and 445 about Thursday Captain. Data was sourced from Quality Boots community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.

282 Reddit opinions analyzed Ā· Last updated 7/11/2026