tldr; 850-fill mummy bag at 2lb 3oz. Runs warm but some find understuffed. Amazing garage sale deals at $60-150. Better bag than quilt version.
Check pricesScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for REI Co-op Magma 15
“REI Magma quilts are actually really quite good. Plus if the kiddo doesn't end up liking the quilt, its an easy return.”
“The one on the list that sticks out is Katabatic. But also you’re missing some key ones like decathlon and Montbell. Montbell Japan was the move but now tariffs and they major thing was them getting away from buying on their Japan website. Was like 40% off at one point with free shipping. The new ghost whisperer is actually good now too. They finally made some updates and there’s always deals you can find on MHW and even bigger bonus if you can get a prodeal from a friend or something. Lastly, I hate this company now, but REI magma hoodie often goes on clearance for under $180.”
161 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 2/24/2026