Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch vs Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
76 facts in comparison
Based on 601 Reddit opinions. Close race—Skillet 10.5-InchStargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch edges ahead.
601 opinions
Skillet 10.5-Inch leads by 1pts
VS
Reddit's Pick
92%
A
Based on
519 Redditors
Winner
Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch
~$175
371 opinions
tldr; Reddit overwhelmingly recommends the Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch. With 92% positive sentiment across 519 mentions, this is a clear community favorite.
Check pricesVS
91%
A
Based on
488 Redditors
Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
~$13.99
230 opinions
tldr; Vintage gold standard. Smooth surface, lighter weight, superior craftsmanship. Collectible prices but unmatched cooking quality.
Check prices🌡️HEA
⭐SEA
🔧BUI
⚖️WEI
⭐VER
80
Points
86
Points
Score by Category
Heat Retention
100%67%
Seasoning
62%79%
Build Quality
92%86%
Weight
73%90%
Versatility
95%100%
Why is Wagner Ware Skillet better than Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch?
- Better weight (90% vs 73%)
- Better seasoning (79% vs 62%)
- Better value (92% vs 59%)
- Users report prices around $121
- Lighter weight than traditional Lodge
- Smooth machined surface for better cooking
Based on 1,007 Reddit opinions
Too Close to Call
Reddit prefers the Skillet 10.5-InchStargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch
Winning by 1 points (92% vs 91%)
Better build quality
Better heat retention
High confidence (1,007 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 1,007 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Skillet 10.5-Inch
9.2/10
519 mentions
Ware Skillet
9.1/10
488 mentions
BUILD QUALITY
Skillet 10.5-Inch9.2/10
Ware Skillet8.6/10
WEIGHT
Skillet 10.5-Inch7.3/10
Ware Skillet9.0/10
VERSATILITY
Skillet 10.5-Inch9.5/10
Ware Skillet10.0/10
VALUE
Skillet 10.5-Inch5.9/10
Ware Skillet9.2/10
SEASONING
Skillet 10.5-Inch6.2/10
Ware Skillet7.9/10
HEAT RETENTION
Skillet 10.5-Inch10.0/10
Ware Skillet6.7/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Skillet 10.5-Inch | Ware Skillet |
|---|---|---|
Build Quality | 92% | 86% |
Weight | 73% | 90% |
Versatility | 95% | 100% |
Value | 59% | 92% |
Seasoning | 62% | 79% |
Heat Retention | 100% | 67% |
Category Wins
Skillet 10.5-Inch: 2|Ware Skillet: 4
Head to Head
Skillet 10.5-Inch: 2|Ware Skillet: 4
Build QualitySkillet 10.5-Inch
Skillet 10.5-Inch92%
Ware Skillet86%
WeightWare Skillet
Skillet 10.5-Inch73%
Ware Skillet90%
VersatilityWare Skillet
Skillet 10.5-Inch95%
Ware Skillet100%
ValueWare Skillet
Skillet 10.5-Inch59%
Ware Skillet92%
SeasoningWare Skillet
Skillet 10.5-Inch62%
Ware Skillet79%
Heat RetentionSkillet 10.5-Inch
Skillet 10.5-Inch100%
Ware Skillet67%
Skillet 10.5-Inch
92%
91%
Ware Skillet
Skillet 10.5-Inch92%
Ware Skillet91%
Close race - Skillet 10.5-Inch edges ahead by 1 points
Key Specs
| Spec | Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch | Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet |
|---|---|---|
| Rim Diameter | 10.5 inches | — |
| Cooking Surface Diameter | 8.1 inches | — |
| Capacity | 2.3 quarts (9.2 cups) | — |
| Material | Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Made In | USA | — |
Key Highlights
Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-InchWinner
Solid community reputation
Frequently recommended
Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
💰 Users report prices around $121
⚖ ️ Lighter weight than traditional Lodge
✨ Smooth machined surface for better cooking
🏆 Users report 90+ years of reliable use
💵 Community agrees it's worth the price premium
Topic Battles
Skillet 10.5-Inch: 2|Tied: 0|Ware Skillet: 3
🌡️Heat Retention
Skillet 10.5-Inch winsSkillet 10.5-Inch
100%
Ware Skillet
67%
⭐Seasoning
Ware Skillet winsSkillet 10.5-Inch
62%
Ware Skillet
79%
🔧Build Quality
Skillet 10.5-Inch winsSkillet 10.5-Inch
92%
Ware Skillet
86%
⚖️Weight
Ware Skillet winsSkillet 10.5-Inch
73%
Ware Skillet
90%
⭐Versatility
Ware Skillet winsSkillet 10.5-Inch
95%
Ware Skillet
100%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch
Best Praise
+18 pts“My 10.5 Stargazer has a similar mottled seasoning and cooks like a fuckin dream. ”
r/castiron
ViewTop Criticism
+6 pts“I have a stargazer. It’s machine smooth. I doesn’t hold seasoning at all. It literally just disintegrates as I’m cooking.”
r/castiron
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
Best Praise
+112 pts“It did get stolen....and then the next round my other gift was taken so I was able to get the Wagner back again! Suckers”
r/castiron
ViewTop Criticism
+6 pts“That's the red headed step child of Wagner. Not really an original Wagner. Was made in the 90s after the company name had changed hands a few times. It'll work fine, but isn't worth jack.”
r/castiron
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
Ware Skillet
📈Historical Price Data
Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch
Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch
All-time low: $132(2024-12)
Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet
All-time low!
Which is Better?
Too Close to Call
Both products have nearly identical approval ratings (92% vs 91%). Choose based on your specific needs and preferences.
Why Skillet 10.5-Inch
Why Ware Skillet
- Better Value for Money (92% vs 59%)
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
66%Positive
Positive
66%Neutral
29%Negative
5%Based on 519 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
44%Positive
Positive
44%Neutral
53%Negative
3%Based on 488 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch or Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet?
Based on 1,007 Reddit comments, Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch has a slight edge with 92% positive sentiment vs Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet's 91%. The difference is small, so both are solid choices.
Should I buy Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch or Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet?
Both have similar approval ratings (92% vs 91%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch?
Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch has 519 mentions on Reddit with 92% positive sentiment. Users consistently recommend it based on real ownership experiences.
What do Redditors say about Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet?
Reddit users highlight: Users report prices around $121. Lighter weight than traditional Lodge. Smooth machined surface for better cooking. With 488 mentions and 91% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,007 Reddit comments: 519 about Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet 10.5-Inch and 488 about Vintage Wagner Ware Skillet. Data was sourced from Cast Iron community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
601 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 4/10/2026