Samsung HW-Q800D vs Sony Bravia Theater Quad

“Highly dependant on the room, but that goes for any and all setups. Atmos isn't solely dependant on the upfiring speakers either, but work in conjunction with *all* of the speakers. Definitely not a gimmick. Not comparable to in-ceiling speakers, but it will 100% enhance the sound in a meaningful way. The quality of the mix itself and how it was mixed matters a tonne too. I'm using the Theatre Quads, and some streamed movies might have a sensation of stuff moving above. But when I play something like Dune on 4k blu-ray, it's **spot on**.”

“People having a right go at you here in the comments. If it works for you, then it works for you. If not, then your dissatisfaction is part of your education on the matter. My first soundbar, a Hisense, was initially satisfactory but as time went on, I was increasingly dissatisfied to the point where I got a Q800d and I've been happy ever since Sometimes the first time works out, sometimes you need to get burnt so that you learn”