NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss vs Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
121 facts in comparison
Based on 636 Reddit opinions. Butter GlossNYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss leads by 22 points.
636 opinions
Butter Gloss leads by 22pts
VS
Reddit's Pick
90%
A
Based on
660 Redditors
Winner
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
~$5.97
336 opinions
tldr; Reddit mostly mentions NYX Butter Gloss in product lists, with one user noting inconsistency in shades between batches.
Check pricesVS
68%
C+
Based on
617 Redditors
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
~$15
300 opinions
tldr; Reddit comments mostly list Tarte Shape Tape Concealer as a product used, with one user noting poor results when blended with a finger.
Check prices⭐FOR
⏱️LON
🎨SHA
❤️SKI
📦PAC
71
Points
52
Points
Score by Category
Formula & Performance
77%44%
Longevity
60%65%
Shade Range
88%71%
Skin Compatibility
33%42%
Packaging
0%25%
Why is Shape Tape Concealer better than Makeup Butter Gloss?
- Better skin compatibility (42% vs 33%)
- May look "pretty bad" if blended with a finger.
Based on 1,277 Reddit opinions
Clear Winner
Reddit prefers the Butter GlossNYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Winning by 22 points (90% vs 68%)
Better formula
Better value
Better shade range
High confidence (1,277 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 1,277 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Butter Gloss
9.0/10
660 mentions
Tape Concealer
6.8/10
617 mentions
FORMULA
Butter Gloss7.7/10
Tape Concealer4.4/10
VALUE
Butter Gloss9.7/10
Tape Concealer6.7/10
LONGEVITY
Butter Gloss6.0/10
Tape Concealer6.5/10
SHADE RANGE
Butter Gloss8.8/10
Tape Concealer7.1/10
SKIN COMPATIBILITY
Butter Gloss3.3/10
Tape Concealer4.2/10
PACKAGING
Butter Gloss0.0/10
Tape Concealer2.5/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Butter Gloss | Tape Concealer |
|---|---|---|
Formula | 77% | 44% |
Value | 97% | 67% |
Longevity | 60% | 65% |
Shade Range | 88% | 71% |
Skin Compatibility | 33% | 42% |
Packaging | 0% | 25% |
Category Wins
Butter Gloss: 3|Tape Concealer: 3
Head to Head
Butter Gloss: 3|Tape Concealer: 3
FormulaButter Gloss
Butter Gloss77%
Tape Concealer44%
ValueButter Gloss
Butter Gloss97%
Tape Concealer67%
LongevityTape Concealer
Butter Gloss60%
Tape Concealer65%
Shade RangeButter Gloss
Butter Gloss88%
Tape Concealer71%
Skin CompatibilityTape Concealer
Butter Gloss33%
Tape Concealer42%
PackagingTape Concealer
Butter Gloss0%
Tape Concealer25%
Butter Gloss
90%
68%
Tape Concealer
Butter Gloss90%
Tape Concealer68%
Clear winner - Butter Gloss leads by 22 points
Key Specs
| Spec | NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss | Tarte Shape Tape Concealer |
|---|---|---|
| Finish | High shine | Matte |
| Texture | Non-sticky, buttery smooth | — |
| Coverage | Sheer to medium | Full |
| Scent | Sweet | — |
| Formula | Enriched with beeswax (in some variants) | — |
Key Highlights
NYX Professional Makeup Butter GlossWinner
⚠ ️ Inconsistent shades between batches
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
⚠️ May look "pretty bad" if blended with a finger.
Topic Battles
Butter Gloss: 2|Tied: 0|Tape Concealer: 3
⭐Formula & Performance
Butter Gloss winsButter Gloss
77%
Tape Concealer
44%
⏱️Longevity
Tape Concealer winsButter Gloss
60%
Tape Concealer
65%
🎨Shade Range
Butter Gloss winsButter Gloss
88%
Tape Concealer
71%
❤️Skin Compatibility
Tape Concealer winsButter Gloss
33%
Tape Concealer
42%
📦Packaging
Tape Concealer winsButter Gloss
0%
Tape Concealer
25%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Best Praise
+70 pts“look for a neutral / warm toned lip liner that’s light in color. try nyx! they have so many colors to choose from”
r/MakeupAddiction
ViewTop Criticism
+87 pts“NYX changed factories for many products, resulting in their OG shades not being the same. The biggest change was in the lip liners, specifically Nude Beige and Nude Truffle. They pull way warmer.”
r/MakeupAddiction
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Best Praise
+10 pts“Tarte Shape Tape. If I can only choose one, that’s it for sure!”
r/MakeupAddiction
ViewTop Criticism
+151 pts“Thank you! I would say the color corrector and the concealor brush were game changers. I started out just using Shape Tape and a finger to blend and TBH that looked pretty bad.”
r/MakeupAddiction
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
Butter Gloss
Tape Concealer
📈Historical Price Data
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
All-time low: $0.01(2024-04)
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
All-time low: $7.93(2019-01)
Which is Better?
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Wins
90%
Gloss
vs
68%
Concealer
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss leads by 22 points based on 1,277 Reddit opinions.
Why Butter GlossWinner
- Better Value for Money (97% vs 67%)
Why Tape Concealer
- ⚠️ May look "pretty bad" if blended with a finger.
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
46%Positive
Positive
46%Neutral
49%Negative
5%Based on 660 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
33%Positive
Positive
33%Neutral
51%Negative
16%Based on 617 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss or Tarte Shape Tape Concealer?
Based on 1,277 Reddit comments, NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss is the preferred choice with 90% positive sentiment vs Tarte Shape Tape Concealer's 68%. NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss leads by 22 percentage points.
Should I buy NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss or Tarte Shape Tape Concealer?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss has stronger approval ratings (90% vs 68%). However, Tarte Shape Tape Concealer may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss?
Reddit users highlight: Inconsistent shades between batches. With 660 mentions and 90% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Tarte Shape Tape Concealer?
Reddit users highlight: May look "pretty bad" if blended with a finger.. With 617 mentions and 68% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,277 Reddit comments: 660 about NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss and 617 about Tarte Shape Tape Concealer. Data was sourced from Makeup products community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
636 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/24/2026