Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo vs Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
91 facts in comparison
Based on 809 Reddit opinions. Care ShampooNot Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo leads by 32 points.
809 opinions
Care Shampoo leads by 32pts
VS
Reddit's Pick
80%
B+
Based on
821 Redditors
Winner
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo
~$16.99
494 opinions
tldr; Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo is a popular and effective choice for curly hair, praised for being a gentle cleanser that enhances curls, though some may find it too mild.
Check pricesVS
48%
D
Based on
675 Redditors
Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
~$35.98
315 opinions
tldr; Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo is a frequently recommended product, though its accompanying conditioner may be too heavy for fine hair.
Check prices⭐CUR
⭐HOL
⭐MOI
⚖️PRO
⭐ING
67
Points
36
Points
Score by Category
Curl Definition
70%50%
Hold
70%33%
Moisture & Hydration
47%45%
Product Weight
50%1%
Ingredients
64%10%
Why is & Shine Shampoo better than Curl Care Shampoo?
- ⭐ Highly recommended by users.
- The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy
- Used weekly by some users as part of their
Based on 1,496 Reddit opinions
Clear Winner
Reddit prefers the Care ShampooNot Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo
Winning by 32 points (80% vs 48%)
Better ingredients
Better hold
Better value
High confidence (1,496 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 1,496 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Care Shampoo
8.0/10
821 mentions
Shine Shampoo
4.8/10
675 mentions
INGREDIENTS
Care Shampoo6.4/10
Shine Shampoo1.0/10
HOLD
Care Shampoo7.0/10
Shine Shampoo3.3/10
VALUE
Care Shampoo9.8/10
Shine Shampoo7.5/10
WEIGHT
Care Shampoo5.0/10
Shine Shampoo0.1/10
MOISTURE
Care Shampoo4.7/10
Shine Shampoo4.5/10
CURL DEFINITION
Care Shampoo7.0/10
Shine Shampoo5.0/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Care Shampoo | Shine Shampoo |
|---|---|---|
Ingredients | 64% | 10% |
Hold | 70% | 33% |
Value | 98% | 75% |
Weight | 50% | 1% |
Moisture | 47% | 45% |
Curl Definition | 70% | 50% |
Category Wins
Care Shampoo: 5|Shine Shampoo: 0
Head to Head
Care Shampoo: 5|Shine Shampoo: 0
IngredientsCare Shampoo
Care Shampoo64%
Shine Shampoo10%
HoldCare Shampoo
Care Shampoo70%
Shine Shampoo33%
ValueCare Shampoo
Care Shampoo98%
Shine Shampoo75%
WeightCare Shampoo
Care Shampoo50%
Shine Shampoo1%
Moisture
Care Shampoo47%
Shine Shampoo45%
Curl DefinitionCare Shampoo
Care Shampoo70%
Shine Shampoo50%
Care Shampoo
80%
48%
Shine Shampoo
Care Shampoo80%
Shine Shampoo48%
Clear winner - Care Shampoo leads by 32 points
Key Specs
| Spec | Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo | Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo |
|---|---|---|
| Hair Type | All curly hair types (2A-4C) | Thick, curly, wavy, kinky, coily hair |
| Formula Attributes | Sulfate surfactant-free, silicone-free, paraben-free, phthalate-free, drying alcohol-free, gluten-free, dye-free, cruelty-free | — |
| Key Ingredients | Rice Curl Complex (rice, keratin amino acids, enzymes), Shea Butter | Coconut Oil, Fair-Trade Shea Butter, Hibiscus Flower Extract, Silk Protein, Neem Oil |
| Scent | Citrus Jasmine | — |
| Usage | Leave-in, rinse-out, or co-wash | — |
Key Highlights
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care ShampooWinner
⭐ Praised for taking curls to "a whole other
⭐ Described as a gentle cleanser.
⭐ Recommended as a lighter shampoo option.
⭐ Part of a popular and effective overall routine.
⚠ Might not be cleansing enough for some users.
Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
⭐ Highly recommended by users.
⚠ The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy
⚙ Used weekly by some users as part of their
Some users report issues (25% negative)
Topic Battles
Care Shampoo: 4|Tied: 1|Shine Shampoo: 0
⭐Curl Definition
Care Shampoo winsCare Shampoo
70%
Shine Shampoo
50%
⭐Hold
Care Shampoo winsCare Shampoo
70%
Shine Shampoo
33%
⭐Moisture & Hydration
Care Shampoo
47%
Shine Shampoo
45%
⚖️Product Weight
Care Shampoo winsCare Shampoo
50%
Shine Shampoo
1%
⭐Ingredients
Care Shampoo winsCare Shampoo
64%
Shine Shampoo
10%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo
Best Praise
+1151 pts“I have very similar hair and I use herbal essence orange mousse followed by nym curl talk gel and it works awesome neither are expensive.”
r/curlyhair
ViewTop Criticism
+35 pts“My husband hates the scent of the Curl Talk line. I got two different variations of NYM, kids and curl definition shampoo/conditioner, and he has no problem with it. But if I touch the refreshing foam, he knows immediately. Turned the bathroom fan on it offended him so much 🤣”
r/curlyhair
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
Best Praise
+11 pts“One thing that’s been getting me is people saying shea moister is bad for your hair. It’s the only thing I’ve found that’s works for me in my budget. People said to try mielle but it made my hair texture feel bad but now I can’t get out of my head that shea moisturizer is bad and keep trying other things that make my hair not look so great.”
r/curlyhair
ViewTop Criticism
+104 pts“I'd maybe not go the Shea moisture route since it's also very heavy in oils and can weigh most hair types down quite a bit/have the same effect as the oil the OP has been using”
r/curlyhair
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
Care Shampoo
Shine Shampoo
📈Historical Price Data
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo
Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo
All-time low: $5.85(2022-08)
$7 below 90-day avg
Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
All-time low: $16.99(2022-01)
Which is Better?
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo Wins
80%
Shampoo
vs
48%
Shampoo
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo leads by 32 points based on 1,496 Reddit opinions.
Why Care ShampooWinner
- Better Value for Money (98% vs 75%)
Why Shine Shampoo
- ⭐ Highly recommended by users.
- ⚠ The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
49%Positive
Positive
49%Neutral
39%Negative
12%Based on 821 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
21%Positive
Positive
21%Neutral
54%Negative
25%Based on 675 Reddit opinions
Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care ShampooCheck prices Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine ShampooCheck prices
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo or Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?
Based on 1,496 Reddit comments, Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo is the preferred choice with 80% positive sentiment vs Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo's 48%. Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo leads by 32 percentage points.
Should I buy Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo or Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo has stronger approval ratings (80% vs 48%). However, Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo?
Reddit users highlight: Praised for taking curls to "a whole other. Described as a gentle cleanser.. Recommended as a lighter shampoo option.. With 821 mentions and 80% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?
Reddit users highlight: Highly recommended by users.. The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy. Used weekly by some users as part of their. With 675 mentions and 48% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,496 Reddit comments: 821 about Not Your Mother's Curl Talk Curl Care Shampoo and 675 about Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo. Data was sourced from Curly hair products community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
809 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/12/2026