Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara vs NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
126 facts in comparison
Based on 964 Reddit opinions. Too close to call.
964 opinions
High Mascara
VS
Reddit's Pick
90%
A
Based on
1,130 Redditors
Winner
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
~$10.82
628 opinions
tldr; Dramatic lengthening mascara with flexible brush. Creates wispy, sky-high lashes but requires thorough removal.
Check pricesVS
90%
A
Based on
660 Redditors
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
~$5.97
336 opinions
tldr; Reddit mostly mentions NYX Butter Gloss in product lists, with one user noting inconsistency in shades between batches.
Check prices⭐FOR
⏱️LON
🎨SHA
❤️SKI
📦PAC
77
Points
71
Points
Score by Category
Formula & Performance
67%77%
Longevity
82%60%
Shade Range
100%88%
Skin Compatibility
40%33%
Packaging
0%0%
Why is Makeup Butter Gloss better than Sky High Mascara?
- Better formula (77% vs 67%)
- Inconsistent shades between batches
Based on 1,790 Reddit opinions
Too Close to Call
Reddit prefers the High MascaraMaybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Winning by 0 points (90% vs 90%)
Better longevity
Better skin compatibility
Better shade range
High confidence (1,790 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 1,790 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
High Mascara
9.0/10
1,130 mentions
Butter Gloss
9.0/10
660 mentions
FORMULA
High Mascara6.7/10
Butter Gloss7.7/10
LONGEVITY
High Mascara8.2/10
Butter Gloss6.0/10
VALUE
High Mascara9.5/10
Butter Gloss9.7/10
SKIN COMPATIBILITY
High Mascara4.0/10
Butter Gloss3.3/10
PACKAGING
High Mascara0.0/10
Butter Gloss0.0/10
SHADE RANGE
High Mascara10.0/10
Butter Gloss8.8/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | High Mascara | Butter Gloss |
|---|---|---|
Formula | 67% | 77% |
Longevity | 82% | 60% |
Value | 95% | 97% |
Skin Compatibility | 40% | 33% |
Packaging | 0% | 0% |
Shade Range | 100% | 88% |
Category Wins
High Mascara: 3|Butter Gloss: 1
Head to Head
High Mascara: 3|Butter Gloss: 1
FormulaButter Gloss
High Mascara67%
Butter Gloss77%
LongevityHigh Mascara
High Mascara82%
Butter Gloss60%
Value
High Mascara95%
Butter Gloss97%
Skin CompatibilityHigh Mascara
High Mascara40%
Butter Gloss33%
Packaging
High Mascara0%
Butter Gloss0%
Shade RangeHigh Mascara
High Mascara100%
Butter Gloss88%
High Mascara
90%
90%
Butter Gloss
High Mascara90%
Butter Gloss90%
Dead heat - too close to call
Key Specs
| Spec | Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara | NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss |
|---|---|---|
| Formula Type | Washable | — |
| Brush Type | Flex Tower flexible mascara wand with spiral brush design | — |
| Key Ingredients | Bamboo extract and fibers | — |
| Allergy Tested | Yes | — |
| Ophthalmologist Tested | Yes | — |
Key Highlights
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High MascaraWinner
📌 Impressive length and lift
🔄 Flexible brush separates lashes
📌 Buildable for more drama
💧 Waterproof version holds curl all day
📌 Stubborn to remove - needs oil-based cleanser
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
⚠ ️ Inconsistent shades between batches
Topic Battles
High Mascara: 3|Tied: 1|Butter Gloss: 1
⭐Formula & Performance
Butter Gloss winsHigh Mascara
67%
Butter Gloss
77%
⏱️Longevity
High Mascara winsHigh Mascara
82%
Butter Gloss
60%
🎨Shade Range
High Mascara winsHigh Mascara
100%
Butter Gloss
88%
❤️Skin Compatibility
High Mascara winsHigh Mascara
40%
Butter Gloss
33%
📦Packaging
High Mascara
0%
Butter Gloss
0%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Best Praise
+84 pts“I used maybelline colossal for years until sky high came out now I use that all the time. I really don’t think you can go wrong with a maybelline mascara. I tried essence once but wasn’t impressed.”
r/MakeupAddiction
ViewTop Criticism
+4 pts“I feel like sky high isn't true tubing. Like the tubes do come off with water but I also get panda eyes. Meanwhile modelco lash extend seems fully tubing where only tubes come off with zero black smudges.”
r/MakeupAddiction
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Best Praise
+70 pts“look for a neutral / warm toned lip liner that’s light in color. try nyx! they have so many colors to choose from”
r/MakeupAddiction
ViewTop Criticism
+87 pts“NYX changed factories for many products, resulting in their OG shades not being the same. The biggest change was in the lip liners, specifically Nude Beige and Nude Truffle. They pull way warmer.”
r/MakeupAddiction
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
High Mascara
Butter Gloss
📈Historical Price Data
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
All-time low: $2.99(2021-10)
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
All-time low: $0.01(2024-04)
Which is Better?
Too Close to Call
Both products have nearly identical approval ratings (90% vs 90%). Choose based on your specific needs and preferences.
Why High Mascara
- 📌 Impressive length and lift
- 🔄 Flexible brush separates lashes
- 📌 Buildable for more drama
- More discussed (1,130 vs 660)
Why Butter Gloss
- ⚠ ️ Inconsistent shades between batches
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
51%Positive
Positive
51%Neutral
44%Negative
5%Based on 1,130 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
46%Positive
Positive
46%Neutral
49%Negative
5%Based on 660 Reddit opinions
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High MascaraCheck prices NYX Professional Makeup Butter GlossCheck prices
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara or NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss?
Based on 1,790 Reddit comments, both are similarly rated at 90% and 90% positive - too close to call a clear winner.
Should I buy Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara or NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss?
Both have similar approval ratings (90% vs 90%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara?
Reddit users highlight: Impressive length and lift. Flexible brush separates lashes. Buildable for more drama. With 1,130 mentions and 90% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss?
Reddit users highlight: Inconsistent shades between batches. With 660 mentions and 90% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,790 Reddit comments: 1,130 about Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara and 660 about NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss. Data was sourced from Makeup products community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
964 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/24/2026