Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart vs Vintage Griswold Skillet
102 facts in comparison
Based on 212 Reddit opinions. Too close to call.
212 opinions
5 Quart
VS
Reddit's Pick
90%
A
Based on
185 Redditors
Winner
Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
~$59.9
100 opinions
tldr; Reddit overwhelmingly recommends the Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart. With 95% positive sentiment across 186 mentions, this is a clear community favorite.
Check pricesVS
90%
A
Based on
193 Redditors
Vintage Griswold Skillet
112 opinions
tldr; Vintage gold standard. Smooth surface, lighter weight, superior craftsmanship. Collectible prices but unmatched cooking quality.
Check prices🌡️HEA
⭐SEA
🔧BUI
⚖️WEI
⭐VER
83
Points
89
Points
Score by Category
Heat Retention
100%—
Seasoning
100%80%
Build Quality
75%96%
Weight
33%100%
Versatility
97%100%
Why is Vintage Griswold Skillet better than Oven 5 Quart?
- Better build quality (96% vs 75%)
- Better weight (100% vs 33%)
- Users report prices around $190
- Lighter weight than traditional Lodge
- Smooth machined surface for better cooking
Based on 378 Reddit opinions
Too Close to Call
Reddit prefers the 5 QuartLodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
Winning by 0 points (90% vs 90%)
Better value
Better seasoning
High confidence (378 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 378 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
5 Quart
9.0/10
185 mentions
Griswold Skillet
9.0/10
193 mentions
VALUE
5 Quart9.0/10
Griswold Skillet7.1/10
VERSATILITY
5 Quart9.7/10
Griswold Skillet10.0/10
SEASONING
5 Quart10.0/10
Griswold Skillet8.0/10
HEAT RETENTION
5 Quart10.0/10
Griswold SkilletN/A
BUILD QUALITY
5 Quart7.5/10
Griswold Skillet9.6/10
WEIGHT
5 Quart3.3/10
Griswold Skillet10.0/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | 5 Quart | Griswold Skillet |
|---|---|---|
Value | 90% | 71% |
Versatility | 97% | 100% |
Seasoning | 100% | 80% |
Heat Retention | 100% | N/A |
Build Quality | 75% | 96% |
Weight | 33% | 100% |
Category Wins
5 Quart: 3|Griswold Skillet: 3
Head to Head
5 Quart: 3|Griswold Skillet: 3
Value5 Quart
5 Quart90%
Griswold Skillet71%
VersatilityGriswold Skillet
5 Quart97%
Griswold Skillet100%
Seasoning5 Quart
5 Quart100%
Griswold Skillet80%
Heat Retention5 Quart
5 Quart100%
Griswold SkilletN/A
Build QualityGriswold Skillet
5 Quart75%
Griswold Skillet96%
WeightGriswold Skillet
5 Quart33%
Griswold Skillet100%
5 Quart
90%
90%
Griswold Skillet
5 Quart90%
Griswold Skillet90%
Dead heat - too close to call
Key Specs
| Spec | Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart | Vintage Griswold Skillet |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 5 quart | — |
| Material | Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Diameter | 10 1/4 inches | — |
| Seasoning | Pre-seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil | Requires seasoning |
| Lid Type | Self-basting domed lid | — |
Key Highlights
Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
Solid community reputation
Frequently recommended
Vintage Griswold SkilletWinner
💰 Users report prices around $190
⚖ ️ Lighter weight than traditional Lodge
✨ Smooth machined surface for better cooking
🏆 Users report 90+ years of reliable use
💵 Community agrees it's worth the price premium
Topic Battles
5 Quart: 2|Tied: 0|Griswold Skillet: 3
🌡️Heat Retention
5 Quart wins5 Quart
100%
Griswold Skillet
—
⭐Seasoning
5 Quart wins5 Quart
100%
Griswold Skillet
80%
🔧Build Quality
Griswold Skillet wins5 Quart
75%
Griswold Skillet
96%
⚖️Weight
Griswold Skillet wins5 Quart
33%
Griswold Skillet
100%
⭐Versatility
Griswold Skillet wins5 Quart
97%
Griswold Skillet
100%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
Best Praise
+32 pts“I have a Lodge Dutch oven that I absolutely love and use whenever possible. Also, Lodge is made not far from me, so maybe the whole very old American company has something to do with it, too”
r/castiron
ViewTop Criticism
+12 pts“My Lodge dutch oven has cracked and chipped at the handles… disappointing”
r/castiron
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Vintage Griswold Skillet
Best Praise
+59 pts“Came across this at random while poking around estate sales in my area, box was unopened and as it was a Sunday they were practically giving it away. From the newspaper packing material it appears to have been manufactured in 1973 and from the receipt on the box it was then sold in 1982. After that from what I gather it sat undisturbed in this persons house till they passed. Now it's here. I've got a couple of other Griswolds, none in this great of condition, but the others have the traditional cross shaped branding on the bottom. This one is completely bare though, which was odd to me. Can anyone verify if this is a thing that went on during that time period?”
r/castiron
ViewTop Criticism
+36 pts“Moment of silence…. Outside of sentimental value, it was likely a very valuable Griswold…. so sorry for your loss”
r/castiron
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
5 Quart
Griswold Skillet
📈Historical Price Data
Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
Vintage Griswold Skillet
Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart
All-time low: $10(2015-08)
Vintage Griswold Skillet
Which is Better?
Too Close to Call
Both products have nearly identical approval ratings (90% vs 90%). Choose based on your specific needs and preferences.
Why 5 Quart
- Better Value for Money (90% vs 71%)
Why Griswold Skillet
- 💰 Users report prices around $190
- ⚖ ️ Lighter weight than traditional Lodge
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
51%Positive
Positive
51%Neutral
46%Negative
3%Based on 185 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
54%Positive
Positive
54%Neutral
42%Negative
4%Based on 193 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart or Vintage Griswold Skillet?
Based on 378 Reddit comments, both are similarly rated at 90% and 90% positive - too close to call a clear winner.
Should I buy Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart or Vintage Griswold Skillet?
Both have similar approval ratings (90% vs 90%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart?
Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart has 185 mentions on Reddit with 90% positive sentiment. Users consistently recommend it based on real ownership experiences.
What do Redditors say about Vintage Griswold Skillet?
Reddit users highlight: Users report prices around $190. Lighter weight than traditional Lodge. Smooth machined surface for better cooking. With 193 mentions and 90% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 378 Reddit comments: 185 about Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven 5 Quart and 193 about Vintage Griswold Skillet. Data was sourced from Cast Iron community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
212 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 5/1/2026