Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold vs Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

101 facts in comparison

Based on 577 Reddit opinions. Create HoldInnersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold leads by 36 points.

577 opinions

Create Hold leads by 36pts

Reddit's Pick

84%

B+

Based on

443 Redditors

Winner

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

~$28

262 opinions

tldr; Strong-hold gel that creates excellent cast on wet hair. Polyquat-free formula works for sensitive scalps. Curls last 5-7 days without refresh.

Check prices

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

48%

Based on

675 Redditors

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

~$35.98

315 opinions

tldr; Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo is a frequently recommended product, though its accompanying conditioner may be too heavy for fine hair.

Check prices

⭐CUR

⭐HOL

⭐MOI

⚖️PRO

⭐ING

Points

Score by Category

Curl Definition

100%50%

Hold

81%33%

Moisture & Hydration

42%45%

Product Weight

75%1%

Ingredients

62%10%

Why is & Shine Shampoo better than I Create Hold?

Better value (75% vs 50%)
⭐ Highly recommended by users.
The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy
Used weekly by some users as part of their

Based on 1,118 Reddit opinions

Clear Winner

Reddit prefers the Create HoldInnersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

Winning by 36 points (84% vs 48%)

Better hold

Better curl definition

Better weight

High confidence (1,118 mentions)

💬Reddit Sentiment

Based on 1,118 Reddit mentions

Overall Rating

Create Hold

8.4/10

443 mentions

Shine Shampoo

4.8/10

675 mentions

HOLD

Create Hold8.1/10

Shine Shampoo3.3/10

VALUE

Create Hold5.0/10

Shine Shampoo7.5/10

CURL DEFINITION

Create Hold10.0/10

Shine Shampoo5.0/10

WEIGHT

Create Hold7.5/10

Shine Shampoo0.1/10

INGREDIENTS

Create Hold6.2/10

Shine Shampoo1.0/10

MOISTURE

Create Hold4.2/10

Shine Shampoo4.5/10

⚔️

Head to Head

Topic	Create Hold	Shine Shampoo
Hold	81%	33%
Value	50%	75%
Curl Definition	100%	50%
Weight	75%	1%
Ingredients	62%	10%
Moisture	42%	45%

Category Wins

Create Hold: 4|Shine Shampoo: 2

Head to Head

Create Hold: 4|Shine Shampoo: 2

HoldCreate Hold

Create Hold81%

Shine Shampoo33%

ValueShine Shampoo

Create Hold50%

Shine Shampoo75%

Curl DefinitionCreate Hold

Create Hold100%

Shine Shampoo50%

WeightCreate Hold

Create Hold75%

Shine Shampoo1%

IngredientsCreate Hold

Create Hold62%

Shine Shampoo10%

MoistureShine Shampoo

Create Hold42%

Shine Shampoo45%

Create Hold

84%

48%

Shine Shampoo

Create Hold84%

Shine Shampoo48%

Clear winner - Create Hold leads by 36 points

Key Specs

Spec	Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold	Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
Key Ingredients	Aloe Vera, Honey, Eucalyptus Oil, Rooibos Tea	Coconut Oil, Fair-Trade Shea Butter, Hibiscus Flower Extract, Silk Protein, Neem Oil
Hold Level	Firm hold	—
Fragrance	Orange Blossom	—
Hair Type	All hair types, best for curly to tight curls	Thick, curly, wavy, kinky, coily hair
Formulation	Honey based styling gel	—

Key Highlights

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create HoldWinner

💪 Creates strong cast - use nickel-sized amount

✨ Curls last 5-7 days w/o refreshing when applied

🌿 Polyquat-free & organic - great for

💵 Pricey ($28/10oz) but 32oz refill available for

❤️ Replaced entire multi-product routines for

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

⭐ Highly recommended by users.

⚠ The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy

⚙ Used weekly by some users as part of their

Some users report issues (25% negative)

Topic Battles

Create Hold: 4|Tied: 0|Shine Shampoo: 1

⭐Curl Definition

Create Hold wins

Create Hold

100%

Shine Shampoo

50%

⭐Hold

Create Hold wins

Create Hold

81%

Shine Shampoo

33%

⭐Moisture & Hydration

Shine Shampoo wins

Create Hold

42%

Shine Shampoo

45%

⚖️Product Weight

Create Hold wins

Create Hold

75%

Shine Shampoo

⭐Ingredients

Create Hold wins

Create Hold

62%

Shine Shampoo

10%

Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories

📈Where They Rank

💬What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

Best Praise

+38 pts

“I love Innersense. It's what my salon switched to after Deva reformulated and ruined everything. I resisted the $25 bottles of gel for as long as I could, but made the switch about 8 months ago. Those bottles end up lasting longer than I would have expected and my hair loves it. I'm probably spending the same or a little less on products than I did before with significantly better results. Really frustrating when the expensive one ends up being the good one, lol. I love the way their shampoo and conditioner smells as well, but I haven't made that plunge yet. I'm still pretty happy with my shampoo and conditioner combos that I've been using for a while. And I found my shampoo and conditioner matters a lot less as long as I'm using the right amount of conditioner and the correct hold products.”

r/curlyhair

View

Top Criticism

+10 pts

“My hair loves Innersense, but I can’t get a super strong hold from their gels (I tried I Create Hold and I Create Curl Memory). Both gels gave me soft smooth loose waves with only a slight cast. I have very, very fine hair that tends to be soft and waves drop out quickly without super strong hold gels. I have had better results with Harry’s gel and the Not Your Mother’s Hard Hold gel (not the Sculpting gel, which is medium hold). The Innersense product that had surprisingly strong hold for me was the I Create Definition foam!”

r/curlyhair

View

3 more quotes available below

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

Best Praise

+11 pts

“One thing that’s been getting me is people saying shea moister is bad for your hair. It’s the only thing I’ve found that’s works for me in my budget. People said to try mielle but it made my hair texture feel bad but now I can’t get out of my head that shea moisturizer is bad and keep trying other things that make my hair not look so great.”

r/curlyhair

View

Top Criticism

+104 pts

“I'd maybe not go the Shea moisture route since it's also very heavy in oils and can weigh most hair types down quite a bit/have the same effect as the oil the OP has been using”

r/curlyhair

View

3 more quotes available below

Sentiment Over Time

Create Hold

Shine Shampoo

📈Historical Price Data

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

All-time low: $18.99(2023-05)

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

All-time low: $16.99(2022-01)

Which is Better?

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold Wins

84%

Hold

48%

Shampoo

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold leads by 36 points based on 1,118 Reddit opinions.

Why Create HoldWinner

💪 Creates strong cast - use nickel-sized amount
✨ Curls last 5-7 days w/o refreshing when applied
🌿 Polyquat-free & organic - great for

Why Shine Shampoo

Better Value for Money (75% vs 50%)
More discussed (675 vs 443)

❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown

Sentiment Breakdown

51%Positive

Positive

51%

Neutral

40%

Negative

Based on 443 Reddit opinions

Sentiment Breakdown

21%Positive

Positive

21%

Neutral

54%

Negative

25%

Based on 675 Reddit opinions

Specification Comparison

Spec	Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold	Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
Key Ingredients	Aloe Vera, Honey, Eucalyptus Oil, Rooibos Tea	Coconut Oil, Fair-Trade Shea Butter, Hibiscus Flower Extract, Silk Protein, Neem Oil
Hold Level	Firm hold	—
Fragrance	Orange Blossom	—
Hair Type	All hair types, best for curly to tight curls	Thick, curly, wavy, kinky, coily hair
Formulation	Honey based styling gel	—
Brand	INNERSENSE	Shea Moisture
Manufacturer	INNERSENSE	Sundial Brands LLC
Color	Clear	White/Cream
Weight	295 ml	384 milliliters
Formula	—	Sulfate-free, no silicones, parabens, phthalates, mineral oils
Benefits	—	Moisturizes, protects, improves elasticity, reduces breakage, controls frizz, adds shine
Height	—	5.51 inches

Feature Checklist

Create Hold: 6|Shine Shampoo: 2

Feature	Create Hold	Shine Shampoo
CLEAN QUALITY: Ingredients Straight From Nature, Grown Organically + Sustainably Without Chemicals - Ethically Harvested + Sourced From Trusted, Transparent Plantations, Orchards + Farms From Around The World.
Creates strong cast - use nickel-sized amount
Curls last 5-7 days w/o refreshing when applied
Polyquat-free & organic - great for
Replaced entire multi-product routines for
WHAT IT IS: A Honey-Based, Natural Styling Gel For Structured Hold + Healthy Shine.
⭐ Highly recommended by users.
The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy

Features extracted from Reddit highlights and enrichment data

⚔️Head to Head

Metric	Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold	Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo
Reddit Score	84%	48%
Mentions	443	675
Sentiment	+ 224- 38	+ 144- 171

Where to Buy

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold

Price unavailableCheck prices

All-time low was $18.99 on 2023-05

~5K sold/month on Amazon

Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo

Price unavailableCheck prices

All-time low was $16.99 on 2022-01

~400 sold/month on Amazon

Prices may vary. We may earn a commission from purchases made through these links.

Innersense Organic Beauty I Create HoldCheck prices Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine ShampooCheck prices

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold or Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?

Based on 1,118 Reddit comments, Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold is the preferred choice with 84% positive sentiment vs Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo's 48%. Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold leads by 36 percentage points.

Should I buy Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold or Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?

If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold has stronger approval ratings (84% vs 48%). However, Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.

What do Redditors love about Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold?

Reddit users highlight: Creates strong cast - use nickel-sized amount. Curls last 5-7 days w/o refreshing when applied. Polyquat-free & organic - great for. With 443 mentions and 84% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.

What do Redditors say about Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo?

Reddit users highlight: Highly recommended by users.. The accompanying conditioner can be too heavy. Used weekly by some users as part of their. With 675 mentions and 48% approval, it remains a popular alternative.

How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?

This comparison analyzed 1,118 Reddit comments: 443 about Innersense Organic Beauty I Create Hold and 675 about Shea Moisture Coconut & Hibiscus Curl & Shine Shampoo. Data was sourced from Curly hair products community discussions.

How accurate are these ratings?

Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.

Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?

Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.

577 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/11/2026

View full Curly hair products guide Browse all guides