Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket vs Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly

87 facts in comparison

These products are from different categories (First Aid Kits vs Skincare products), so direct comparison may not be meaningful.

Based on 421 Reddit opinions. Close raceβ€”Petroleum Jelly edges ahead.

421 opinions
Petroleum Jelly leads by 5pts
Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket
68%
C+
Based on
77 Redditors

Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket

~$11.87
34 opinions

tldr; Space blanket. Prevents hypothermia, weighs nothing.

Check prices
VS
Reddit's Pick
Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly
73%
B-
Based on
1,009 Redditors
Winner

Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly

~$5.48
387 opinions

tldr; Reddit highly recommends Vaseline for its exceptional healing, moisturizing, and occlusive properties, often favored by dermatologists and praised for its affordability.

Check prices
Item QualityValue
βœ“ITE
πŸ’°VAL
70
Points
76
Points

Score by Category

Item Quality
40%β€”
Value
100%100%

Why is Original Petroleum Jelly better than Mylar Thermal Blanket?

  • Higher Reddit score (73% vs 68%)
  • Dermatologist rec'd for healing after minor
  • ⏱ Heals skin fast and effectively
  • Works as an effective, affordable occlusive
Based on 1,086 Reddit opinions
Slight Edge

Reddit prefers the Petroleum Jelly

Winning by 5 points (73% vs 68%)

Dermatologist rec'd for healing after minor
Heals skin fast and effectively
Works as an effective, affordable occlusive
High confidence (1,086 mentions)

πŸ’¬Reddit Sentiment

Based on 1,086 Reddit mentions

Overall Rating

Thermal Blanket
6.8/10
77 mentions
Petroleum Jelly
7.3/10
1,009 mentions
BUILD QUALITY
Thermal Blanket4.0/10
Petroleum JellyN/A
VALUE
Thermal Blanket10.0/10
Petroleum Jelly10.0/10
EFFECTIVENESS
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly7.3/10
INGREDIENTS
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly6.7/10
SKIN FEEL
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly5.0/10
GENTLENESS
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly8.8/10
βš”οΈ

Head to Head

Head to Head

Thermal Blanket: 1|Petroleum Jelly: 4
Build QualityThermal Blanket
Thermal Blanket40%
Petroleum JellyN/A
Value
Thermal Blanket100%
Petroleum Jelly100%
EffectivenessPetroleum Jelly
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly73%
IngredientsPetroleum Jelly
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly67%
Skin FeelPetroleum Jelly
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly50%
GentlenessPetroleum Jelly
Thermal BlanketN/A
Petroleum Jelly88%
Thermal Blanket68%
Petroleum Jelly73%
Petroleum Jelly wins by 5 points

Key Specs

SpecEmergency Mylar Thermal BlanketVaseline Original Petroleum Jelly
Material
Mylar (aluminized polyethylene terephthalate film)
β€”
Heat Retention
Reflects up to 90% of body heat
β€”
Dimensions Unfolded
84 inches x 52 inches
β€”
Dimensions Packaged
Typically 4.25 inches x 4.25 inches x 0.5 inches
β€”
Waterproof
Yes
β€”

Key Highlights

Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket
πŸ₯Ά Hypothermia prevention
πŸͺΆ Ultra light
πŸ’° Cheap
🎯 Essential
Vaseline Original Petroleum JellyWinner
πŸ† Dermatologist rec'd for healing after minor
⏱️ Heals skin fast and effectively
πŸ’° Works as an effective, affordable occlusive
🎯 Leaves skin feeling amazing overnight
πŸ’§ Excellent for extremely dry skin when layered

Topic Battles

Thermal Blanket: 1|Tied: 1|Petroleum Jelly: 0
βœ“Item Quality
Thermal Blanket wins
Thermal Blanket
40%
Petroleum Jelly
β€”
πŸ’°Value
Thermal Blanket
100%
Petroleum Jelly
100%

Based on Reddit sentiment across 2 categories

πŸ“ˆWhere They Rank

πŸ’¬What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly

Best Praise
+49 pts
β€œMy dermatologist won’t let me put anything on my face after any minor surgery by Vaseline. Not even aquapore- just Vaseline. My skin healed so fast. Supposedly to remove stitches it take 4-7bdays, but my skin healed up so fast they have to remove the stitches in 3 days tops. Any wound, dryness - this is all that doctors recommend. My mom also swears that putting light Vaseline on your face and rinsing it before you get out of the shower and applying make up after, your make up will be vibrant and last longer. She was an actress in the 70s and this is how the production make up artist does her make up.”
r/SkincareAddiction
View
Top Criticism
+11 pts
β€œI guess whoever who hasn't tried it yet, give it a go . But I've since learned during the winter trying to combat dry air, that dabbing a a little Vaseline a bit around my face, causes my face to break out like crazy the next day. Oh the night of, it is shiny and moist and lovely. But the next day, big ol bright red zits”
r/SkincareAddiction
View
3 more quotes available below

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket

Best Praise
+25 pts
β€œEmergency mylar blankets are my rarely used item, but when I have needed them, I was glad to have them!”
r/CampingGear
View
Top Criticism
+35 pts
β€œI've slept with a mylar blanket a lot. Firstly, they are nice and neat and very small in their packaging, however once you unfold it etc. You will never get it back to its small size. Another thing, they are very loud. They make lots of noise, I repeat VERY loud when your moving etc. Also, one blanket isn't quite enough trust me on this! Two blankets taped together is the way to go. I want to say the coldest temperature I used a mylar blanket in was around 15 degrees Fahrenheit. Which is really cold. I was also sleeping in a car in the backseat with a foldable front window sun visor underneath me. I also had a fleece throw blanket over me to hold the mylar in place better and to keep the noise down. I survived that night, I was still cold and didn't sleep well, but I made it and in an shtf scenario it's better than nothing. I'd save for an ultralight sleeping bag with liner honestly.”
r/preppers
View
3 more quotes available below

πŸ“ˆHistorical Price Data

Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket
Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly
$6$9$12$15Jun '25Jul '25Sep '25Oct '25Dec '25Jan '26Jan '26Mar '26Apr '26May '26Low: $5.64Low: $5.97Current: $11.39Current: $9.99
Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket
All-time low: $1.99(2013-12)
Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly
All-time low: $2.29(2022-05)

Which is Better?

Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly Wins
73%
Jelly
vs
68%
Blanket

Close race, but Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly edges ahead by 5 points based on 1,086 Reddit opinions.

Why Petroleum JellyWinner
  • πŸ† Dermatologist rec'd for healing after minor
  • ⏱️ Heals skin fast and effectively
  • πŸ’° Works as an effective, affordable occlusive
  • More discussed (1,009 vs 77)
Why Thermal Blanket
  • πŸ₯Ά Hypothermia prevention
  • πŸͺΆ Ultra light

❀️The Love/Hate Breakdown

Sentiment Breakdown

28%Positive
Positive
28%
Neutral
62%
Negative
10%
Based on 1,009 Reddit opinions

Sentiment Breakdown

27%Positive
Positive
27%
Neutral
56%
Negative
17%
Based on 77 Reddit opinions

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly or Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket?
Based on 1,086 Reddit comments, Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly has a slight edge with 73% positive sentiment vs Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket's 68%. The difference is small, so both are solid choices.
Should I buy Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly or Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket?
Both have similar approval ratings (73% vs 68%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly?
Reddit users highlight: Dermatologist rec'd for healing after minor. Heals skin fast and effectively. Works as an effective, affordable occlusive. With 1,009 mentions and 73% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket?
Reddit users highlight: Hypothermia prevention. Ultra light. Cheap. With 77 mentions and 68% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,086 Reddit comments: 1,009 about Vaseline Original Petroleum Jelly and 77 about Emergency Mylar Thermal Blanket. Data was sourced from First Aid Kits community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.

421 Reddit opinions analyzed Β· Last updated 6/16/2026