Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots vs Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean

54 facts in comparison

Based on 24 Reddit opinions. Close race—Vintage Jean edges ahead.

24 opinions
Vintage Jean leads by 4pts
Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots
71%
B-
Based on
51 Redditors

Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots

Limited Data
~$141.62
16 opinions

tldr; Reddit users praise Doc Martens for their durability, longevity, and versatility as an everyday staple for various personal styles.

Check prices
VS
Reddit's Pick
Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean
75%
B
Based on
12 Redditors
Winner

Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean

Limited Data
~$148
8 opinions

tldr; Madewell's Perfect Vintage Jean line is a popular 'go-to' for many due to its fit and variety of cuts, though some users report issues with color fading.

Check prices
FitQualityStyle & VersatilityWash & Care
📐FIT
🔧QUA
STY
WAS
60
Points
67
Points

Score by Category

Fit
20%100%
Quality
33%
Style & Versatility
100%
Wash & Care
0%

Why is Perfect Vintage Jean better than Lace Up Boots?

  • Higher Reddit score (75% vs 71%)
  • Better fit (100% vs 20%)
  • ⭐ Praised as a 'go-to' for specific body
  • users experience discoloring of Madewell jeans
Based on 63 Reddit opinions
Too Close to Call

Reddit prefers the Vintage Jean

Winning by 4 points (75% vs 71%)

Better fit
Praised as a 'go-to' for specific body
Available in various cuts within the line
Medium confidence (63 mentions)

💬Reddit Sentiment

Based on 63 Reddit mentions

Overall Rating

Up Boots
7.1/10
51 mentions
Vintage Jean
7.5/10
12 mentions
FIT
Up Boots2.0/10
Vintage Jean10.0/10
STYLE
Up Boots10.0/10
Vintage JeanN/A
BUILD QUALITY
Up BootsN/A
Vintage Jean3.3/10
WASH CARE
Up BootsN/A
Vintage Jean0.0/10
⚔️

Head to Head

Head to Head

Up Boots: 1|Vintage Jean: 2
FitVintage Jean
Up Boots20%
Vintage Jean100%
StyleUp Boots
Up Boots100%
Vintage JeanN/A
Build QualityVintage Jean
Up BootsN/A
Vintage Jean33%
Wash Care
Up BootsN/A
Vintage Jean0%
Up Boots71%
Vintage Jean75%
Close race - Vintage Jean edges ahead by 4 points

Key Specs

SpecDr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up BootsMadewell The Perfect Vintage Jean
Upper Material
Smooth leather
Sole Type
Air-cushioned Airwair outsole
Construction
Goodyear welt
Eyelets
8-eye
Heel Height
1.25 inch

Key Highlights

Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up BootsWinner
⭐ Praised as versatile everyday shoes.
⚙ Known for exceptional longevity, w/ owning
✓ Can be treated w/ waterproof spray for added
⭐ A staple for diverse styles, from edgy to
Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean
⭐ Praised as a 'go-to' for specific body
⭐ Available in various cuts within the line
⚠ users experience discoloring of Madewell jeans

Topic Battles

Up Boots: 1|Tied: 1|Vintage Jean: 2
📐Fit
Vintage Jean wins
Up Boots
20%
Vintage Jean
100%
🔧Quality
Vintage Jean wins
Up Boots
Vintage Jean
33%
Style & Versatility
Up Boots wins
Up Boots
100%
Vintage Jean
Wash & Care
Up Boots
Vintage Jean
0%

Based on Reddit sentiment across 4 categories

📈Where They Rank

💬What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean

Best Praise
+3 pts
Honestly I go for Madewell and avoid their curvy styles, and stick to their Perfect Vintage line. I have the same proportional issue on my lower half and am around the same size and height. Their “curvy” styles have reduced in quality because they use a good amount of polyester/elastane and increased it, but their perfect vintage has remained the same in my experience!
r/femalefashionadvice
View
Top Criticism
+3 pts
I just spent 3.5 hours shopping for jeans and had absolutely zero luck. Where did all the robust curvy styles go??? 😭 I’m 5’3”, usually size 8/10, with a pear shape body. Basically I have a fat ass and smaller waist. And I just tried on some jeans from Aritiza (7 diff styles), AE, and Gap. In the past, Madewell would work but they rarely have curvy styles in store anymore and the quality has gone down too much for me to want to spend so much. But listen. I will spend $200 for a perfect pair. I just don’t know where to look. I love all styles and will try new trends. I just need something that doesn’t look like my ass is eating jeans while simultaneously having a large gap at my waist. I don’t think my body type is that outrageous. Please help.
r/femalefashionadvice
View
3 more quotes available below

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots

Best Praise
+3 pts
I have a pair of off brand doc martens that I have worn pretty much every day this winter. They aren’t as visually versatile imo but I still love what they do for every outfit
r/femalefashionadvice
View
Top Criticism
+5 pts
Same, I had to “break in” my leather Blundstones, but it was mainly the upper leather portion over the top of my foot was a little tight and just needed to stretch out. Doc Martens, however, NEVER broke in for me and were miserable to wear right away and always.
r/femalefashionadvice
View
3 more quotes available below

📈Historical Price Data

Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots
Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean
$120$140$160$180Jul '25Nov '25Feb '26Feb '26Mar '26Mar '26Mar '26Apr '26Apr '26May '26Low: $139.58Low: $133.2Current: $141.46Current: $133.2
Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots
All-time low: $9.49(2017-03)
$5 below 90-day avg
Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean
All-time low!

Which is Better?

Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean Wins
75%
Jean
vs
71%
Boots

Close race, but Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean edges ahead by 4 points based on 63 Reddit opinions.

Why Vintage JeanWinner
  • ⭐ Praised as a 'go-to' for specific body
  • ⭐ Available in various cuts within the line
  • ⚠ users experience discoloring of Madewell jeans
Why Up Boots
  • ⭐ Praised as versatile everyday shoes.
  • ⚙ Known for exceptional longevity, w/ owning
  • More discussed (51 vs 12)

❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown

Sentiment Breakdown

50%Positive
Positive
50%
Neutral
33%
Negative
17%
Based on 12 Reddit opinions

Sentiment Breakdown

20%Positive
Positive
20%
Neutral
68%
Negative
12%
Based on 51 Reddit opinions

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean or Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots?
Based on 63 Reddit comments, Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean has a slight edge with 75% positive sentiment vs Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots's 71%. The difference is small, so both are solid choices.
Should I buy Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean or Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots?
Both have similar approval ratings (75% vs 71%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean?
Reddit users highlight: Praised as a 'go-to' for specific body. Available in various cuts within the line. users experience discoloring of Madewell jeans. With 12 mentions and 75% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots?
Reddit users highlight: Praised as versatile everyday shoes.. Known for exceptional longevity, w/ owning. Can be treated w/ waterproof spray for added. With 51 mentions and 71% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 63 Reddit comments: 12 about Madewell The Perfect Vintage Jean and 51 about Dr. Martens 1460 Smooth Leather Lace Up Boots. Data was sourced from Women's Clothing community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.

24 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 7/27/2026