Derby Extra Super Stainless vs Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop
56 facts in comparison
Based on 500 Reddit opinions. - BarbershopStirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop leads by 34 points.
500 opinions
- Barbershop leads by 34pts
VS
63%
C
Based on
396 Redditors
Derby Extra Super Stainless
~$7.99
228 opinions
tldr; Polarizing blade. Some love the smoothness, others find it tuggy. Cheap enough to try. Works great in mild razors.
Check pricesVS
Reddit's Pick
SS
- Barbershop
97%
A+
Based on
410 Redditors
Winner
Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop
272 opinions
tldr; Highly praised for close shaves, good value.
Check prices✓SHA
⭐BLA
🔧BUI
⭐LAT
✋ERG
79
Points
73
Points
Score by Category
Shave Quality
46%100%
Blade Feel
48%50%
Build Quality
0%50%
Lather Quality
100%92%
Ergonomics
100%50%
Why is Soap - Barbershop better than Extra Super Stainless?
- Higher Reddit score (97% vs 63%)
- Better shave quality (100% vs 46%)
- Delivers smooth, close shaves
- Excellent value for the price point
- Requires proper technique and experience
Based on 806 Reddit opinions
Clear Winner
Reddit prefers the - BarbershopStirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop
Winning by 34 points (97% vs 63%)
Better shave quality
Delivers smooth, close shaves
Excellent value for the price point
High confidence (806 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 806 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Super Stainless
6.3/10
396 mentions
- Barbershop
9.7/10
410 mentions
SHAVE QUALITY
Super Stainless4.6/10
- Barbershop10.0/10
BLADE FEEL
Super Stainless4.8/10
- Barbershop5.0/10
VALUE
Super Stainless10.0/10
- Barbershop9.8/10
BUILD QUALITY
Super Stainless0.0/10
- Barbershop5.0/10
LATHER
Super Stainless10.0/10
- Barbershop9.2/10
ERGONOMICS
Super Stainless10.0/10
- Barbershop5.0/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Super Stainless | - Barbershop |
|---|---|---|
Shave Quality | 46% | 100% |
Blade Feel | 48% | 50% |
Value | 100% | 98% |
Build Quality | 0% | 50% |
Lather | 100% | 92% |
Ergonomics | 100% | 50% |
Category Wins
Super Stainless: 2|- Barbershop: 2
Head to Head
Super Stainless: 2|- Barbershop: 2
Shave Quality- Barbershop
Super Stainless46%
- Barbershop100%
Blade Feel
Super Stainless48%
- Barbershop50%
Value
Super Stainless100%
- Barbershop98%
Build Quality- Barbershop
Super Stainless0%
- Barbershop50%
LatherSuper Stainless
Super Stainless100%
- Barbershop92%
ErgonomicsSuper Stainless
Super Stainless100%
- Barbershop50%
Super Stainless
63%
97%
- Barbershop
Super Stainless63%
- Barbershop97%
Clear winner - - Barbershop leads by 34 points
Key Specs
| Spec | Derby Extra Super Stainless | Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Material | Stainless steel | — |
| Coating | Chromium, ceramic, polymer, tungsten, and platinum | — |
| Compatibility | Fits all standard double edge safety razors | — |
| Manufacturing Origin | Turkey | — |
| Brand | Derby | — |
Key Highlights
Derby Extra Super Stainless
💰 ~$0.10 per blade cheap
⚖️ Mild, smooth shave feel
🎲 YMMV - divisive blade
🪒 Best in mild razors
📦 100-pack sampler staple
Some users report issues (22% negative)
Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - BarbershopWinner
🪒 Delivers smooth, close shaves
💰 Excellent value for the price point
🎯 Requires proper technique and experience
Topic Battles
Super Stainless: 2|Tied: 1|- Barbershop: 2
✓Shave Quality
- Barbershop winsSuper Stainless
46%
- Barbershop
100%
⭐Blade Feel
Super Stainless
48%
- Barbershop
50%
🔧Build Quality
- Barbershop winsSuper Stainless
0%
- Barbershop
50%
⭐Lather Quality
Super Stainless winsSuper Stainless
100%
- Barbershop
92%
✋Ergonomics
Super Stainless winsSuper Stainless
100%
- Barbershop
50%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Derby Extra Super Stainless
Sentiment Over Time
Super Stainless
- Barbershop
📈Historical Price Data
Derby Extra Super Stainless
Derby Extra Super Stainless
All-time low: $1.99(2011-12)
Which is Better?
Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop Wins
97%
Barbershop
vs
63%
Stainless
Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop leads by 34 points based on 806 Reddit opinions.
Why - BarbershopWinner
- 🪒 Delivers smooth, close shaves
- 💰 Excellent value for the price point
- 🎯 Requires proper technique and experience
Why Super Stainless
- 💰 ~$0.10 per blade cheap
- ⚖️ Mild, smooth shave feel
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
66%Positive
Positive
66%Neutral
33%Negative
1%Based on 410 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
35%Positive
Positive
35%Neutral
43%Negative
22%Based on 396 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop or Derby Extra Super Stainless?
Based on 806 Reddit comments, Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop is the preferred choice with 97% positive sentiment vs Derby Extra Super Stainless's 63%. Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop leads by 34 percentage points.
Should I buy Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop or Derby Extra Super Stainless?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop has stronger approval ratings (97% vs 63%). However, Derby Extra Super Stainless may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop?
Reddit users highlight: Delivers smooth, close shaves. Excellent value for the price point. Requires proper technique and experience. With 410 mentions and 97% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Derby Extra Super Stainless?
Reddit users highlight: 0.10 per blade cheap. Mild, smooth shave feel. YMMV - divisive blade. With 396 mentions and 63% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 806 Reddit comments: 410 about Stirling Soap Co. Shave Soap - Barbershop and 396 about Derby Extra Super Stainless. Data was sourced from Shaving gear community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
500 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/25/2026