Creed Aventus vs Guerlain Shalimar
96 facts in comparison
Based on 774 Reddit opinions. Guerlain ShalimarGuerlain Shalimar leads by 23 points.
774 opinions
Guerlain Shalimar leads by 23pts
VS
59%
C-
Based on
1,217 Redditors
Creed Aventus
~$380
487 opinions
tldr; Creed Aventus is a highly hyped fragrance, with some finding it overrated upon first smell, while others still consider it a desirable and popular choice.
Check pricesVS
Reddit's Pick
82%
B+
Based on
653 Redditors
Winner
Guerlain Shalimar
~$175
287 opinions
tldr; Guerlain Shalimar is an iconic and historic perfume, celebrated for its unique vanilla notes and rich, sometimes controversial, past, with L'Essence being particularly praised.
Check prices💨SCE
⏱️LON
⭐PRO
⭐VER
⭐UNI
56
Points
75
Points
Score by Category
Scent Profile
50%68%
Longevity
43%82%
Projection & Sillage
67%50%
Versatility
100%67%
Uniqueness
57%100%
Why is Guerlain Shalimar better than Creed Aventus?
- Higher Reddit score (82% vs 59%)
- Better scent profile (68% vs 50%)
- Better value (82% vs 20%)
- Better longevity (82% vs 43%)
- Better uniqueness (100% vs 57%)
- Iconic 1925 oriental - perfumery royalty
- ⭐ Shalimar L’Essence is "indescribably good" &
Based on 1,870 Reddit opinions
Clear Winner
Reddit prefers the Guerlain ShalimarGuerlain Shalimar
Winning by 23 points (82% vs 59%)
Better scent profile
Better value
Better longevity
High confidence (1,870 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 1,870 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Creed Aventus
5.9/10
1,217 mentions
Guerlain Shalimar
8.2/10
653 mentions
SCENT PROFILE
Creed Aventus5.0/10
Guerlain Shalimar6.8/10
VALUE
Creed Aventus2.0/10
Guerlain Shalimar8.2/10
LONGEVITY
Creed Aventus4.3/10
Guerlain Shalimar8.2/10
PROJECTION
Creed Aventus6.7/10
Guerlain Shalimar5.0/10
UNIQUENESS
Creed Aventus5.7/10
Guerlain Shalimar10.0/10
VERSATILITY
Creed Aventus10.0/10
Guerlain Shalimar6.7/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Creed Aventus | Guerlain Shalimar |
|---|---|---|
Scent Profile | 50% | 68% |
Value | 20% | 82% |
Longevity | 43% | 82% |
Projection | 67% | 50% |
Uniqueness | 57% | 100% |
Versatility | 100% | 67% |
Category Wins
Creed Aventus: 2|Guerlain Shalimar: 4
Head to Head
Creed Aventus: 2|Guerlain Shalimar: 4
Scent ProfileGuerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus50%
Guerlain Shalimar68%
ValueGuerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus20%
Guerlain Shalimar82%
LongevityGuerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus43%
Guerlain Shalimar82%
ProjectionCreed Aventus
Creed Aventus67%
Guerlain Shalimar50%
UniquenessGuerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus57%
Guerlain Shalimar100%
VersatilityCreed Aventus
Creed Aventus100%
Guerlain Shalimar67%
Creed Aventus
59%
82%
Guerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus59%
Guerlain Shalimar82%
Clear winner - Guerlain Shalimar leads by 23 points
Key Specs
| Spec | Creed Aventus | Guerlain Shalimar |
|---|---|---|
| Fragrance Family | Chypre Fruity | — |
| Concentration | Eau de Parfum | — |
| Top Notes | Bergamot, Black Currant, Apple, Lemon, Pink Pepper | — |
| Heart Notes | Pineapple, Patchouli, Moroccan Jasmine, Rose | — |
| Base Notes | Birch, Musk, Oakmoss, Cedarwood, Ambroxan | — |
Key Highlights
Creed Aventus
⚠ Considered "one of the hyped up fragrances of
⚠ users find it disappointing or overrated after
⭐ Still a popular & desirable fragrance, often
✓ Its popularity leads to concerns ~
Guerlain ShalimarWinner
👑 Iconic 1925 oriental - perfumery royalty
⭐ Shalimar L’Essence is "indescribably good" &
⭐ Considered by as "the greatest perfume" from
⚠ Users express regret over limited editions
Topic Battles
Creed Aventus: 2|Tied: 0|Guerlain Shalimar: 3
💨Scent Profile
Guerlain Shalimar winsCreed Aventus
50%
Guerlain Shalimar
68%
⏱️Longevity
Guerlain Shalimar winsCreed Aventus
43%
Guerlain Shalimar
82%
⭐Projection & Sillage
Creed Aventus winsCreed Aventus
67%
Guerlain Shalimar
50%
⭐Versatility
Creed Aventus winsCreed Aventus
100%
Guerlain Shalimar
67%
⭐Uniqueness
Guerlain Shalimar winsCreed Aventus
57%
Guerlain Shalimar
100%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Guerlain Shalimar
Best Praise
+150 pts“I've told versions of this story on reddit over the years so I swear I'm not a bot, I am the authentic "wore Shalimar to jail" girl: My late teens and early twenties were the definition of a cautionary tale, but I got lucky at the final hour and was able to clean up my act with only moderate damage. I'm a very different person now, but I raised a lot of hell when I was young. After I got clean I wore Shalimar as a daily driver during what was arguably one of the most peaceful times in my life. Unfortunately I still had to pay off some of the debts I incurred during my dumbass era and that eventually involved turning myself in to get rid of my warrant for walking off probation years before. Now, I was naive enough to think that because I'd legitimately turned my life around, been doing volunteer work, all the right things, that even with priors I would just be ordered to attend classes and pay a fine. But what ended up happening was I served ten days out of my ninety beginning immediately. So I was all made up pretty as a picture and instead of going to lunch with my dad afterwards, I went directly to jail. If you've never been (and I can't say I recommend it, though between jail and psych I'd choose jail) there are a few funny things that happen when you're incarcerated. One of these things is that you and everyone around you achieve this nearly zenlike state of boredom. *Everything* mundane that isn't just sitting around becomes exciting, even sweeping the floor. Another is that you revert to this high school mentality of making fast best friends, because since there's nothing to do but talk you end up hearing everyone's life story in short order and getting paper for passing notes or doodling is *the shit*. The strangest and most relevant to the funny part (it's coming I promise) though is that everything and everyone start to smell the same. All of your personal products are the same, because they all come from commissary. All of the blankets and clothes are washed in the same industrial laundry. Everyone is eating the same food. It's very odd and slightly maddening if you're a scent driven person. Pretty much the only personal belonging you keep is your underwear, and your bra if it doesn't have an underwire. I prefer sports bras or no bras, so I got to keep my bra... And the dirty little secret that while it wasn't exactly funky it had been worn a few times, and each time with Shalimar. I was using the EDT at the time and what I didn't realize until then was that when you remove every other source of olfactory stimulation, several day's worth of drydown from even just the EDT built up on fabric is definitely noticeable. I started to get this light whiff of almost a spiced almond vanilla pudding, and while we were flopped in our boats just doing nothing I casually mentioned to my cellmate that my bra was the only thing on the whole block that smelled good. So she came over and invited herself to smell my boobs and then dragged me out to the common room to tell everyone else to smell my boobs. For the rest of the day and into the next couple I had random chicks coming over like "Can I get a hit of that?" and sticking their nose into my nonexistent cleavage, then exclaiming that it still smelled good. The male guard was like "Knock that shit off, ladies" at the bizarre pack of wild dogs act but the female guard was entertained as hell by the whole thing and gave us a piece of paper to tear up so I could write down the name. There are probably still scraps of paper floating around metro Detroit with Wayne County on one side and "Guerlain—Shalimar—EDT" in my chicken scratch on the other lmfao. As a note I've attempted to recreate this by spraying it directly into my bra daily and wearing it right to the edge of "Ew wash that thing" and I've never been able to get it to hit as noticeably as that again. It really was a phenomenon born out of the homogeneous scent-deprived nature of the setting. But it's still by far my favorite goofy jail story. Tl;dr: Did not pass go, went directly to jail, became an olfactory prison bitch (thanks, Mariah)”
r/fragrance
ViewTop Criticism
+38 pts“I had a NIGHTMARE experience with Guerlain recently so even they’re not immune: I ordered a bottle of Shalimar l’essence and I came with something like a bug leg floating in it. I don’t think I’m being unfair to ask for an exchange but it took more than a month (with zero apologies or niceties, multiple emails and calls on my part to get them to respond) for them to decide that the only thing they could do was give me a refund once I sent it back. Maddening all the way around. (And yes, definitely provided photos and videos of the offending problem)”
r/fragrance
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Creed Aventus
Top Criticism
+60 pts“It was Creed Aventus. I had been wearing Aventus for a while by then and was kind of getting a bit tired of it anyway. Him wearing 10 sprays of that sht everyday from January to July was the nail in the coffin though. I'm like yeah, I'm good. I don't want to be that dude or even associated with that smell anymore. It was one of the things that made me switch to more personal, light wearing fragrances. I didn't even want my fragrance to be noticed or project anymore lol. It came off as tacky and desperate.”
r/fragrance
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
Creed Aventus
Guerlain Shalimar
📈Historical Price Data
Creed Aventus
Guerlain Shalimar
Creed Aventus
All-time low: $300.86(2020-05)
Guerlain Shalimar
All-time low: $74.09(2025-06)
Which is Better?
Guerlain Shalimar Wins
82%
Shalimar
vs
59%
Aventus
Guerlain Shalimar leads by 23 points based on 1,870 Reddit opinions.
Why Guerlain ShalimarWinner
- Better Value for Money (82% vs 20%)
Why Creed Aventus
- ⚠ Considered "one of the hyped up fragrances of
- ⚠ users find it disappointing or overrated after
- More discussed (1,217 vs 653)
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
36%Positive
Positive
36%Neutral
56%Negative
8%Based on 653 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
23%Positive
Positive
23%Neutral
60%Negative
17%Based on 1,217 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Guerlain Shalimar or Creed Aventus?
Based on 1,870 Reddit comments, Guerlain Shalimar is the preferred choice with 82% positive sentiment vs Creed Aventus's 59%. Guerlain Shalimar leads by 23 percentage points.
Should I buy Guerlain Shalimar or Creed Aventus?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Guerlain Shalimar has stronger approval ratings (82% vs 59%). However, Creed Aventus may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about Guerlain Shalimar?
Reddit users highlight: Iconic 1925 oriental - perfumery royalty. Shalimar L’Essence is "indescribably good" &. Considered by as "the greatest perfume" from. With 653 mentions and 82% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Creed Aventus?
Reddit users highlight: Considered "one of the hyped up fragrances of. users find it disappointing or overrated after. Still a popular & desirable fragrance, often. With 1,217 mentions and 59% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,870 Reddit comments: 653 about Guerlain Shalimar and 1,217 about Creed Aventus. Data was sourced from Perfumes & colognes community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
774 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 6/7/2026