Arko Shaving Soap Stick vs Proraso Shaving Cream

66 facts in comparison

Based on 912 Reddit opinions. Close raceβ€”Shaving Cream edges ahead.

912 opinions
Shaving Cream leads by 2pts
Arko Shaving Soap Stick
89%
A-
Based on
777 Redditors

Arko Shaving Soap Stick

~$15.95
495 opinions

tldr; Highly praised for smooth and comfortable, close shaves.

Check prices
VS
Reddit's Pick
Proraso Shaving Cream
91%
A
Based on
740 Redditors
Winner

Proraso Shaving Cream

~$10
417 opinions

tldr; Highly praised for smooth and comfortable, solid build quality.

Check prices
Shave QualityBlade FeelBuild QualityLather QualityErgonomics
βœ“SHA
⭐BLA
πŸ”§BUI
⭐LAT
βœ‹ERG
92
Points
70
Points

Score by Category

Shave Quality
88%85%
Blade Feel
0%50%
Build Quality
β€”0%
Lather Quality
90%70%
Ergonomics
β€”50%

Why is Proraso Shaving Cream better than Shaving Soap Stick?

  • Higher Reddit score (91% vs 89%)
  • Excellent value for the price point
  • Delivers smooth, close shaves
  • May cause irritation for some users
Based on 1,517 Reddit opinions
Too Close to Call

Reddit prefers the Shaving Cream

Winning by 2 points (91% vs 89%)

Excellent value for the price point
Delivers smooth, close shaves
May cause irritation for some users
High confidence (1,517 mentions)

πŸ’¬Reddit Sentiment

Based on 1,517 Reddit mentions

Overall Rating

Soap Stick
8.9/10
777 mentions
Shaving Cream
9.1/10
740 mentions
VALUE
Soap Stick9.9/10
Shaving Cream9.3/10
LATHER
Soap Stick9.0/10
Shaving Cream7.0/10
SHAVE QUALITY
Soap Stick8.8/10
Shaving Cream8.5/10
BLADE FEEL
Soap Stick0.0/10
Shaving Cream5.0/10
BUILD QUALITY
Soap StickN/A
Shaving Cream0.0/10
ERGONOMICS
Soap StickN/A
Shaving Cream5.0/10
βš”οΈ

Head to Head

Head to Head

Soap Stick: 3|Shaving Cream: 2
ValueSoap Stick
Soap Stick99%
Shaving Cream93%
LatherSoap Stick
Soap Stick90%
Shaving Cream70%
Shave QualitySoap Stick
Soap Stick88%
Shaving Cream85%
Blade FeelShaving Cream
Soap Stick0%
Shaving Cream50%
Build Quality
Soap StickN/A
Shaving Cream0%
ErgonomicsShaving Cream
Soap StickN/A
Shaving Cream50%
Soap Stick89%
Shaving Cream91%
Close race - Shaving Cream edges ahead by 2 points

Key Specs

SpecArko Shaving Soap StickProraso Shaving Cream
Type
Triple Milled Shaving Soap Stick
β€”
Key Ingredients
Tallow Fat, Glycerin
Eucalyptus oil, Menthol, Glycerin
Scent
Fresh powdery fragrance, Lemon Fresh, Classic barbershop scent
Eucalyptus and Menthol
Lather Quality
Rich, creamy, thick, lubricating
β€”
Country Of Origin
Turkey
β€”

Key Highlights

Arko Shaving Soap StickWinner
πŸ’° Excellent value for the price point
⚠️ May cause irritation for some users
πŸͺ’ Delivers smooth, close shaves
⚑ Efficient cutting with fewer passes
πŸ’ͺ Solid construction and durable materials
Proraso Shaving Cream
πŸ’° Excellent value for the price point
πŸͺ’ Delivers smooth, close shaves
⚠️ May cause irritation for some users
πŸ’ͺ Solid construction and durable materials
βš–οΈ Lightweight design for easy handling

Topic Battles

Soap Stick: 2|Tied: 1|Shaving Cream: 2
βœ“Shave Quality
Soap Stick wins
Soap Stick
88%
Shaving Cream
85%
⭐Blade Feel
Shaving Cream wins
Soap Stick
0%
Shaving Cream
50%
πŸ”§Build Quality
Soap Stick
β€”
Shaving Cream
0%
⭐Lather Quality
Soap Stick wins
Soap Stick
90%
Shaving Cream
70%
βœ‹Ergonomics
Shaving Cream wins
Soap Stick
β€”
Shaving Cream
50%

Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories

πŸ“ˆWhere They Rank

πŸ’¬What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Proraso Shaving Cream

Best Praise
+14 pts
β€œProraso red is dirt cheap, might wanna pick up one of those in either case.”
r/wicked_edge
View
Top Criticism
+4 pts
β€œI had this issue with proraso. It was annoying so I stopped using it.”
r/wicked_edge
View
3 more quotes available below

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Arko Shaving Soap Stick

Best Praise
+32 pts
β€œI understand Arko. Let's address your points: Smell: It's all down to personal preference. I personally don't mind the smell. Plus, it does fade a bit as it ages. Lather: Yes, this is a product best lathered with a brush. If you're having difficulty lathering, you possibly haven't rubbed enough on your face. Arko should be easy to lather. Container: Again, Personal preference. I unwrap enough the paper to shave with before I get in the shower. If the 'Arko man' on the wrapper is not your cup of tea a simple search for shave stick containers will give you some alternate options. I use a vintage metal Colgate shave stick container in my travel kit. You can always mash or grate it into the container of your choice if the shave stick format is not to your liking. Price: I'm not sure what to say here. It sounds like you paid a premium on purpose. Arko is cheap if you buy in bulk. If you wanted to try it before committing to a 12 stick box, the premium is worth it. Right? We're still not talking huge costs. Here in the UK a single Arko stick on Amazon is still cheaper than Proraso. Even if you compare cost per gram. This may vary depending on your location. In Italy for example, Proraso will be much cheaper. Finally: If you don't like Arko, don't buy it. No one is making you. Other shave sticks are available. Other cheap wet shaving options are available as well.”
r/wicked_edge
View
Top Criticism
+21 pts
β€œIf Arko made a jumper it would be 100% polyester and smelly.”
r/wicked_edge
View
3 more quotes available below

πŸ“ˆHistorical Price Data

Arko Shaving Soap Stick
Proraso Shaving Cream
$8$12$16Aug '25Aug '25Aug '25Oct '25Dec '25Dec '25Feb '26Feb '26Mar '26May '26Low: $14.99Low: $8.5Current: $15.95Current: $10
Arko Shaving Soap Stick
All-time low: $14.99(2024-03)
Proraso Shaving Cream
All-time low: $2.5(2014-09)

Which is Better?

Proraso Shaving Cream Wins
91%
Cream
vs
89%
Stick

Close race, but Proraso Shaving Cream edges ahead by 2 points based on 1,517 Reddit opinions.

Why Shaving CreamWinner
  • πŸ’° Excellent value for the price point
  • πŸͺ’ Delivers smooth, close shaves
  • ⚠️ May cause irritation for some users
Why Soap Stick
  • Better Value for Money (99% vs 93%)

❀️The Love/Hate Breakdown

Sentiment Breakdown

52%Positive
Positive
52%
Neutral
43%
Negative
5%
Based on 740 Reddit opinions

Sentiment Breakdown

57%Positive
Positive
57%
Neutral
37%
Negative
6%
Based on 777 Reddit opinions

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Proraso Shaving Cream or Arko Shaving Soap Stick?
Based on 1,517 Reddit comments, Proraso Shaving Cream has a slight edge with 91% positive sentiment vs Arko Shaving Soap Stick's 89%. The difference is small, so both are solid choices.
Should I buy Proraso Shaving Cream or Arko Shaving Soap Stick?
Both have similar approval ratings (91% vs 89%), so focus on specific features, pricing, and what matters most to you.
What do Redditors love about Proraso Shaving Cream?
Reddit users highlight: Excellent value for the price point. Delivers smooth, close shaves. May cause irritation for some users. With 740 mentions and 91% approval, it's a well-regarded choice in the community.
What do Redditors say about Arko Shaving Soap Stick?
Reddit users highlight: Excellent value for the price point. May cause irritation for some users. Delivers smooth, close shaves. With 777 mentions and 89% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 1,517 Reddit comments: 740 about Proraso Shaving Cream and 777 about Arko Shaving Soap Stick. Data was sourced from Shaving gear community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.

912 Reddit opinions analyzed Β· Last updated 6/24/2026