Allen Edmonds Park Avenue vs Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt
94 facts in comparison
Based on 227 Reddit opinions. OCBD ShirtSpier & Mackay OCBD Shirt leads by 9 points.
227 opinions
OCBD Shirt leads by 9pts
VS
81%
B+
Based on
216 Redditors
Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
~$450
92 opinions
tldr; Classic American dress shoe. Cap-toe oxford for suits and formal wear. Made in USA but quality debates exist.
Check pricesVS
Reddit's Pick
S&
OCBD Shirt
90%
A
Based on
311 Redditors
Winner
Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt
135 opinions
tldr; Reddit overwhelmingly recommends the Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt. With 93% positive sentiment across 311 mentions, this is a clear community favorite.
Check prices📐FIT
🔧QUA
⭐FAB
⭐STY
⭐DUR
79
Points
87
Points
Score by Category
Fit
60%65%
Quality
62%92%
Fabric & Feel
62%95%
Style
100%75%
Durability
100%100%
Why is Mackay OCBD Shirt better than Edmonds Park Avenue?
- Higher Reddit score (90% vs 81%)
- Better quality (92% vs 62%)
- Better fabric (95% vs 62%)
- Better value (95% vs 88%)
Based on 527 Reddit opinions
Slight Edge
Reddit prefers the OCBD ShirtSpier & Mackay OCBD Shirt
Winning by 9 points (90% vs 81%)
Better quality
Better fabric
Better value
High confidence (527 mentions)
💬Reddit Sentiment
Based on 527 Reddit mentionsOverall Rating
Park Avenue
8.1/10
216 mentions
OCBD Shirt
9.0/10
311 mentions
BUILD QUALITY
Park Avenue6.2/10
OCBD Shirt9.2/10
FABRIC
Park Avenue6.2/10
OCBD Shirt9.5/10
STYLE
Park Avenue10.0/10
OCBD Shirt7.5/10
VALUE
Park Avenue8.8/10
OCBD Shirt9.5/10
FIT
Park Avenue6.0/10
OCBD Shirt6.5/10
DURABILITY
Park Avenue10.0/10
OCBD Shirt10.0/10
⚔️
Head to Head
| Topic | Park Avenue | OCBD Shirt |
|---|---|---|
Build Quality | 62% | 92% |
Fabric | 62% | 95% |
Style | 100% | 75% |
Value | 88% | 95% |
Fit | 60% | 65% |
Durability | 100% | 100% |
Category Wins
Park Avenue: 1|OCBD Shirt: 4
Head to Head
Park Avenue: 1|OCBD Shirt: 4
Build QualityOCBD Shirt
Park Avenue62%
OCBD Shirt92%
FabricOCBD Shirt
Park Avenue62%
OCBD Shirt95%
StylePark Avenue
Park Avenue100%
OCBD Shirt75%
ValueOCBD Shirt
Park Avenue88%
OCBD Shirt95%
FitOCBD Shirt
Park Avenue60%
OCBD Shirt65%
Durability
Park Avenue100%
OCBD Shirt100%
Park Avenue
81%
90%
OCBD Shirt
Park Avenue81%
OCBD Shirt90%
OCBD Shirt wins by 9 points
Key Specs
| Spec | Allen Edmonds Park Avenue | Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Allen Edmonds | Spier & Mackay |
| Manufacturer | Allen Edmonds | Spier & Mackay |
| Color | Black | Various |
| Weight | 3.25 Pounds | — |
| Height | 5.5 inches | — |
Key Highlights
Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
👞 Classic cap-toe oxford
🇺🇸 Made in USA (historically)
👔 Suits and formal occasions
⚠️ Quality control debates
💰 ~$400 price point
Spier & Mackay OCBD ShirtWinner
Solid community reputation
Frequently recommended
Topic Battles
Park Avenue: 1|Tied: 1|OCBD Shirt: 3
📐Fit
OCBD Shirt winsPark Avenue
60%
OCBD Shirt
65%
🔧Quality
OCBD Shirt winsPark Avenue
62%
OCBD Shirt
92%
⭐Fabric & Feel
OCBD Shirt winsPark Avenue
62%
OCBD Shirt
95%
⭐Style
Park Avenue winsPark Avenue
100%
OCBD Shirt
75%
⭐Durability
Park Avenue
100%
OCBD Shirt
100%
Based on Reddit sentiment across 5 categories
📈Where They Rank
💬What Redditors Actually Say
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt
Best Praise
+28 pts“Spier and Mackay had a phenomenal end of season sale that may still be going on”
r/malefashionadvice
ViewTop Criticism
+3 pts“everything is political. > I’m not trying to drag politics into here That's just code that we all quietly understand. It actually means, "I don't want to deal with all the racists." For the past few weeks, people have been posting in r/malefashionadvice about where to get shirts now that Spier & Mackay is expensive. Why is Spier & Mackay expensive now? Did a "politics" happen?”
r/malefashionadvice
View3 more quotes available below
What Redditors Say
Best praise vs top criticism for Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
Best Praise
+10 pts“I’ve been buying Allen Edmonds shoes for 2 decades. There has been a bit of a falloff in quality, but nothing that will really matter. I have a 6-8 pair rotation with several being at least 15 years old. After a couple of years you really can’t tell any difference. I do try to keep my cost below $300. Getting tougher nowadays, but I was able to grab several for $220 in the past. Hell, a new pair of brooks running shoes cost at least $150 and they will not last more than 1-2 years with regular wear.”
r/malefashionadvice
ViewTop Criticism
+3 pts“Allen Edmonds sucks after it was bought by private equity. The quality is so hit or miss. The designs of their non-core items are becoming weirder and catering to the dress shoe-sneaker hybrid crowd. And they are starting to out source now. Not worth the money unless secondhand.”
r/malefashionadvice
View3 more quotes available below
Sentiment Over Time
Park Avenue
OCBD Shirt
📈Historical Price Data
Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
All-time low: $149.43(2017-04)
Which is Better?
Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt Wins
90%
Shirt
vs
81%
Avenue
Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt leads by 9 points based on 527 Reddit opinions.
Why OCBD ShirtWinner
- Better Build Quality (92% vs 62%)
- Better Value for Money (95% vs 88%)
- More discussed (311 vs 216)
Why Park Avenue
- 👞 Classic cap-toe oxford
- 🇺🇸 Made in USA (historically)
❤️The Love/Hate Breakdown
Sentiment Breakdown
41%Positive
Positive
41%Neutral
56%Negative
3%Based on 311 Reddit opinions
Sentiment Breakdown
35%Positive
Positive
35%Neutral
58%Negative
7%Based on 216 Reddit opinions
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt or Allen Edmonds Park Avenue?
Based on 527 Reddit comments, Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt is the preferred choice with 90% positive sentiment vs Allen Edmonds Park Avenue's 81%. Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt leads by 9 percentage points.
Should I buy Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt or Allen Edmonds Park Avenue?
If you want the safer choice based on community sentiment, Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt has stronger approval ratings (90% vs 81%). However, Allen Edmonds Park Avenue may still be better depending on your specific needs, budget, or use case.
What do Redditors love about Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt?
Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt has 311 mentions on Reddit with 90% positive sentiment. Users consistently recommend it based on real ownership experiences.
What do Redditors say about Allen Edmonds Park Avenue?
Reddit users highlight: Classic cap-toe oxford. Made in USA (historically). Suits and formal occasions. With 216 mentions and 81% approval, it remains a popular alternative.
How many Reddit reviews were analyzed?
This comparison analyzed 527 Reddit comments: 311 about Spier & Mackay OCBD Shirt and 216 about Allen Edmonds Park Avenue. Data was sourced from Men's Clothing community discussions.
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Well-discussed products with many mentions tend to have more reliable scores than niche items with fewer data points.
Why trust Reddit over professional reviews?
Reddit users bought products with their own money and have no incentive to mislead. You're seeing hundreds of real opinions across different use cases, not just one reviewer's take. This crowdsourced approach surfaces both common praise and recurring complaints.
227 Reddit opinions analyzed · Last updated 5/31/2026