tldr; Great for pancakes and bacon. Even heat distribution across surface. Takes up space but very useful.
Check pricesScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for Greater Goods Cast Iron Griddle
“No. It just looks like a good example of a fancy handle, gate marked, round griddle. 1880s maybe. Unknown maker”
“Eh not all cast iron is the same. These are rare pieces from the big brands, at a nice booth and seasoned so you can tell the condition (not rolling the dice with rust or buildup). Honestly not a bad price for the square Wagner, not a surprising price for a slant logo #3(?) Griswold round griddle. I wouldn’t call these overpriced, but if you aren’t a collector you could find better condition unmarked pieces for $20 maybe even in the same store.”
2,321 mentions
304 mentions
184 mentions
108 mentions
103 mentions
99 mentions
92 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 2/24/2026