tldr; Spanish craftsmanship. Hand-welted, calf leather, sleek European lasts. Excellent value for European quality. Competes with EG.
Check pricesScores based on sentiment analysis of topic-related comments
Best praise vs top criticism for Carmina Shoemaker Jumper Boot
“From personal experience, buy less but buy better. Buy it not because it’s a good deal, but because it calls out for you. If you are sure about what you like, I’d save up and get a customized pair from Carmina. They have a variety of lady’s lasts, styles, and leathers; they also have custom week when they waive the customization fee.”
“tldr; i don't think shell is any better or worse than any other leather in my collection shell isn't an upgrade, it's just a different material. if you like its qualities, then no other leather really hits the same combination of qualities. if you don't like it's qualities, then it's not worth it. it's ultimately a subjective question, and it's very important to remember that when you're buying shell, you're effectively paying extra for a material swap, and there's no difference in any other aspect of the shoe for that price increase. a carmina with shell is made just the same build as a carmina without shell”
1,120 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 2/24/2026