Brooks Trace 3

Brooks Trace 3

Limited Data$ BudgetTrending Down

tldr; Mixed reception for comfortable, fit-specific. Comfortable daily trainer.

Check prices

Sentiment Breakdown

8%Positive
Positive
8%
Neutral
67%
Negative
25%
Based on 12 Reddit opinions

Strengths & Weaknesses

Each axis shows what % of Reddit comments are positive about that topic. Higher = more praise.

Key Features

  • THIS MEN’S SHOE IS FOR: The Trace 3 is for runners who want a shoe that is going to be soft and dependable.
  • SMOOTH TRANSITIONS: Segmented crash pad cushions your landing and creates a seamless transition from heel-to-toe.
  • UPDATED, SECURE FIT: New engineered air mesh provides breathability and a soft feel.
  • SOFT CUSHIONING: DNA LOFT cushioning is softer than before and also adaptable for lasting comfort mile after mile that reacts to your unique stride.
  • BREATHABLE UPPER: Air-mesh upper offers more breathability to keep runners dry and comfortable.
  • 🛋 ️ Highly cushioned - praised for plush comfort
  • 😊 Comfortable fit - consistently praised for
  • 👟 Fit considerations - check sizing notes

Historical Price Data

Brooks Trace 3
Brooks Trace 3

What Redditors Actually Say

What Redditors Say

Best praise vs top criticism for Brooks Trace 3

Best Praise
+2 pts
Brooks Ghost, Trace, or Glycerin are some of the best for comfort IMO. They’re nothing special, but my Brooks Ghost 14 have lasted me 2 years of constant use through AF basic training and tech school and on all sorts of hikes and rucks. In short, they’re my Ol’ Reliable.
r/RunningShoeGeeks
View
Top Criticism
+1 pts
The one with the black upper, white accents and white midsole? Maybe. I do like a more understated look, but I don't mind a bit of color. I ended up ordering a pair of black Torin 5 Leather, also in wide, to wear for work. Not because I wouldn't wear the grey/red colorway to work, I just didn't want to be putting mileage on my running shoes every day at work. With regard to Brooks, I just remember trying on 2E Trace 3s at a DSW and they felt uncomfortably tight. I then found 4E Ghost 16s, tried them on, and they felt perfect. I bought them and went for a short run in them before returning them and opting for the Torins. Didn't bother trying on 2E Ghost 16s, so I can't directly compare them. Maybe the Ghost 16 just has more width or a more comfortable fit over the Trace 3 to start with. The Trace basically appears to be the budget version of the Ghost anyways. All I can say is that I seem to have exceptionally wide feet - I usually have to go up a half size or full size in regular sneakers or dress shoes to feel comfortable, and I have tailor's bunions from years of trying to squeeze into regular shoes. Both the 4E Ghost 16 and the wide Torin 7 feel completely comfortable on me.
r/RunningShoeGeeks
View
2 more quotes available below

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Brooks Trace 3 worth buying?
Mixed reception for comfortable, fit-specific. Comfortable daily trainer.
What do Redditors love about the Brooks Trace 3?
Redditors highlight: 🛋 ️ Highly cushioned - praised for plush comfort. 😊 Comfortable fit - consistently praised for. 👟 Fit considerations - check sizing notes.
What are the downsides of the Brooks Trace 3?
Some criticisms include: "The one with the black upper, white accents and white midsole? Maybe. I do like a more understated look, but I don't mind a bit of color."
How accurate are these ratings?
Our sentiment analysis is approximately 80-85% accurate compared to manual review. Products with more mentions (Brooks Trace 3 has 12) tend to have more reliable scores.

12 Reddit opinions analyzed • Last updated 7/26/2026